Voting in Kenya: Putting Ethnicity in Perspective

Abstract

Do Kenyans vote according to ethnic identities or policy interests? Based on results from a national probability sample survey conducted in the first week of December 2007, this article shows that, while ethnic origins drive voting patterns, elections in Kenya amount to more than a mere ethnic census. We start by reviewing how Kenyans see themselves, which is mainly in non-ethnic terms. We then report on how they see others, whom they fear will organize politically along ethnic lines. People therefore vote defensively in ethnic blocs, but not exclusively. In Decem-ber 2007, they also took particular policy issues into account, including living standards, corruption and majimbo (federalism). We demonstrate that the relative weight that individuals grant to ethnic and policy voting depends in good part on how they define their group identities, with "ethnics" engaging in identity voting and "non-ethnics" giving more weight to interests and issues.Journal of Economic Literature Classification: D72, D74, D78

Fertilizer and votes: Does strategic economic policy explain the 2009 Malawi election?

“…While the premise of ethnic-identity voting is straightforward, you vote for the candidate/party from your ethnic group, few studies suggest that this is the sole-determinant of vote-choice in Africa. While authors such as Norris and Mattes (2003), Bratton andKimenyi (2008), Eifertetl al. (2010) or Osei-Hwedi (1998) note the importance of ethnicity in electoral outcomes in certain countries, other authors, such as Basedau and Stroh (2012), Batty (2011) or Lindberg and Morrison (2008) find little evidence that ethnicity drives electoral choice.…”

Do African Voters Favor Coethnics? Evidence from a Survey Experiment in Benin

“…On one hand, scholars describe African elections as ethnic head counts (Horowitz, 1985) or emphasize the ethnic factor in African electoral contests (Eifert et al, 2010;Ndegwa, 1997). On the other hand, scholars attempting to tease out ethnicity from typical confounds paint a more nuanced picture of the African voter's decision, highlighting performance evaluation and policy preference instead (e.g., Bratton et al, 2011;Bratton and Kimenyi, 2008;Kimenyi and Romero, 2008;Lindberg and Morrison, 2008;Posner and Simon, 2002). But the fact of the matter is that these observational studies can only speak to the correlation between ethnicity and support; they cannot demonstrate a causal effect.…”

Reform and Political Impunity in Kenya: Transparency without Accountability

“…Adams Oloo (2010:40) argues that those identities have played a greater role in recent years, but "large part [s] of the emergent religious, gender and youth identities are conflated with ethnicity and rarely mature into distinct character of their own. " Michael Bratton and Mwangi Kimenyi (2008) Galloping corruption and a steep decline of merit criteria in civil service recruitment contributed to a weakening and informalization of state institutions even as there were donor efforts to repair old and rebuild new formal institutions as part of the reform agenda (Branch & Cheeseman, 2010). One of the most egregious examples of state personnel undermining institutions, in this case the police, was the practice by which politicians backed private militias for "work" at times of elections (see Mueller 2008).…”