Usage of Plant Food Supplements (PFS) for weight control in six European countries: results from the PlantLIBRA PFS Consumer Survey 2011-2012

Abstract

BackgroundObesity is increasing worldwide and weight-control strategies, including the consumption of plant food supplements (PFS), are proliferating. This article identifies the herbal ingredients in PFS consumed for weight control and by overweight/obese dieters in six European countries, and explores the relationship between their consumption and their self-reported BMI.MethodsData used were a subset from the PlantLIBRA PFS Consumer Survey 2011-2012, a retrospective survey of 2359 PFS consumers. The survey used a bespoke frequency-of-PFS-usage questionnaire. Analyses were performed in two consumer subsamples of 1) respondents taking the products for “body weight reasons”, and 2) “dieters for overweight/obesity”, to identify the herbal ingredients consumed for these reasons. The relationship between the 5 most consumed herbal ingredients and self-reported BMI in groups 1 and 2 is explored by comparing BMI proportions of consumers vs. non-consumers (using Chi-squared test).Results252 PFS (8.8 %) were consumed for “body weight reasons” (by 240 PFS consumers); 112 PFS consumers (4.8 %) were “dieting for overweight/obesity”. Spain is the country where consuming herbal ingredients for body weight control and dieting were most popular. Artichoke was the most consumed herbal ingredient. Considering only the 5 top products consumed by those who responded “body weight”, when using the total survey sample, a greater proportion of BMI ≥ 25 was observed among consumers of PFS containing artichoke and green tea as compared to non-consumers (58.4 % vs. 49.1 % and 63.2 % vs. 49.7 % respectively). Considering only the 5 top products consumed by “dieters” and using only the “dieters” sample, a lower proportion of BMI ≥ 25 was observed among pineapple-containing PFS consumers (38.5 % vs. 81.5 %); however, when using the entire survey sample, a greater proportion of BMI ≥ 25 was observed among artichoke-containing PFS consumers (58.4 % vs. 49.1 %).ConclusionsA comparison of results among the scarce publications evaluating the use of weight-loss supplements at the population level is limited. Nevertheless every hint is important in finding out which are the self-treatment strategies used by overweight/obese individuals in European countries. Although limited by a small sample size, our study represents a first attempt at analysing such data in six EU countries. Our findings should encourage the conduction of further studies on this topic, long-term and large sample-sized studies, ideally conducted in the general population.

Herbal dietary interventions for weight loss among regularly exercising women in Turkey

“…Few studies evaluated the consumption of herbal dietary interventions, but the estimated rates were lower than our study (Eldalo et al, 2017;Lubowiecki-Vikuk et al, 2019a). It must be emphasized that these studies were conducted in general populations, however, the use of herbal dietary interventions is more common among females, especially with excess weight or self-perception of excess weight (Garcia-Alvarez et al, 2016).…”

“…Similar data, especially for green tea, were reported in previous studies (Bahmani et al, 2016;Eldalo et al, 2017). In the European Consumer Survey, the most commonly used herbal products were artichoke, green tea and fennel (Garcia-Alvarez et al, 2016). Nevertheless, a comparison for the use of different herbal products is challenging, owing to variations in the study design, sample sizes and data collection methodology as well as cultural distinctions.…”

Prevalence and Predictors of Self-Medication with Antifungal Drugs and Herbal Products Among University Students: A Cross-Sectional Study from Egypt

“…In contrast, female gender was a common factor associated with this practice in many studies, possibly owing to the great influence of media and society on body appearance, especially for women. 42 , 45 …”

Weight control behaviors among Koreans

“…The multicomponent intervention including behavioral self-monitoring, computer-based training, and motivational interviewing for truck drivers was supported in the United States 12 ) . Additionally, diet or eating behavior programs were recommended for management of overweight and obesity 13 , 14 , 15 ) . Findings suggest obesity management and prevention efforts require multifaceted strategies incorporating education, health policy, public health and health systems, strong primary care workforce, etc 16 ) .…”