Understanding the effects of control and transparency in searching as learning

Abstract

In this paper, we analyze the benefits of adopting user interfaces that offer control and transparency for searching in contexts of learning activities. Concretely, we conducted a user study with pharmacy students performing a problem-solving task in the course of a university lecture. The task involved finding scientific papers containing relevant information to solve a clinical case. Students were split into two independent groups and assigned one search tool to perform the task. The baseline group worked with PubMed, a popular search engine in the life sciences domain, whereas the second half of the class was assigned an exploratory search system (ESS) designed for control and transparency. In the analysis, we cover the objective and subjective dimensions of the task outcomes. Firstly, the objective analysis addresses the inherent difficulty of the search task in a learning scenario and identifies certain improvements in performance for those students using the ESS, most notably when searching for primary-source content. The subjective analysis investigates the human factors side, providing evidence that the ESS effectively increases the perception of control and transparency and is able to produce a better user experience. Lastly, we report on perceived learning as a subjective dimension measured separately from user experience. CCS CONCEPTS • Information systems → Web searching and information discovery; Search interfaces; • Applied computing → Interactive learning environments.

Interactive Visual Facets to Support Fluid Exploratory Search

“…Rather than simply using facets to filter results, SearchLens [3] allows users to personalise search results by adjusting the importance of facet values. In uRank, users can reorder search results according to their relevancy to weighted keywords [7][8][9]. An improved version of uRank incorporated social aspects where users weigh a hybrid model to rank results [5,6].…”

Directing and Combining Multiple Queries for Exploratory Search by Visual Interactive Intent Modeling

“…Simple lookup search is not sufficient for all information seeking: studies estimated up to 50% of searching is informational and the search behavior is exploratory, spreading over multiple queries [9,16]. For example, academic search is exploratory, uncertain, multifaceted and successive [33]: an average scientific search session requires 15 queries [14]. Exploratory search is related to the concept of recommender systems: both help the user find new items of interest.…”