Una invitación al pluralismo legal

Prieto, Manuel; José, Manuel Freire

doi:10.4067/s0718-09502012000100002

Cited by 3 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 31 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…La teoría del pluralismo jurídico surgió como crítica a la teoría del centralismo jurídico, que indica que el derecho solamente deriva del aparato estatal (Prieto Montt, 2012). El pluralismo jurídico propone que el derecho no es exclusivo, ni jerárquico ni sistemático.…”

Section: Resultados Hallazgos Y Nuevo Conocimiento 1 El Principio Dunclassified

Las intervenciones judiciales al arbitraje internacional en Colombia y la seguridad jurídica

Becerra

2015

dialogos

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

resumenLos laudos arbitrales internacionales han encontrado en las acciones constitucionales que protegen los derechos fundamentales un obstáculo para su ejecución y, por ende, también para la seguridad jurídica. Existen algunas jurisdicciones donde el arbitraje es elevado a categoría constitucional y, por tanto, es considerado una institución a proteger que hace parte del orden público interno. Por supuesto, lo anterior colisiona con un arbitraje verdaderamente internacional que termina vulnerando las expectativas de la comunidad internacional de comerciantes, lo que permite argumentar que existe un peligro para la seguridad jurídica. Esta seguridad jurídica no es solo aquella que se aferra a los preceptos del derecho positivo si no es una seguridad jurídica distinta, impregnada de pluralismo y que implica el consenso mancomunado, coordinado y activo de los diversos actores de negocios, quienes dejan de ser entes pasivos para ser co-activos dentro del encadramiento de la seguridad jurídica, especialmente en Colombia donde su estrucutra legal y jurisprudencial parece dudosa de renunciar a sus fuertes tradiciones positivistas. Este artículo utilizó una investigación documental para responder sus planteamientos y, además, inició desde lo general para llegar al caso particular de Colombia.Palabras clave: Arbitraje internacional, Seguridad jurídica, Colombia, Acción de tutela, Pluralismo jurídico. abstractInternational arbitration awards in constitutional actions that protect fundamental rights have found an obstacle to their implementation and therefore also to legal certainty. There are some jurisdictions where arbitration is elevated to constitutional status and therefore it is considered as an institution that is part of internal public order which has to be protected. Of course, the above collides with arbitration that is truly international and that this terminates in violating the expectations of the international business community and which thus promotes the argument that there is a threat to legal certainty. This legal certainty is not only that which clings to the precepts of positive law, if not a distinct legal certainty, steeped in pluralism and implying the joint coordinated and active consensus of the various business participants, who are no longer passive entities but to be contributors within the framework of legal certainty, especially in Colombia where it seems doubtful that its legal and jurisprudential structure will give up its strong positivist tradition. This article used documentary research to answer its approaches and also starts from a general overview then to the particular case of Colombia.

show abstract

Section: Resultados Hallazgos Y Nuevo Conocimiento 1 El Principio Dunclassified

Las intervenciones judiciales al arbitraje internacional en Colombia y la seguridad jurídica

Becerra

2015

dialogos

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…It is troubling that the idiosyncrasies of the numerous different legal families are not meaningfully assessed in studies spanning more than one legal family as evidenced in, for example, Arthaud-Day (2005), Barthe (2007) and Hawn and Ioannou (2016). Even when legal pluralism is recognized (Ferrazzo and Lixa, 2017; Lythreatis et al, 2019; Miska et al, 2016; Prieto Montt, 2012), a primacy of Occidental jurisprudence can be inferred. Ergo, the differences have not been satisfactorily assessed to identify their implications for CSR.…”

Section: Impossibility Of Overcoming Coloniality In Compliance and Csrmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…Since then, the world has moved on. Nowadays, the world is increasingly characterized by legal pluralism (Ferrazzo and Lixa, 2017; Prieto Montt, 2012). There has been a blindness for Indigenous nations’ laws in legal history (Duve, 2012), but Indigenous nations’ autonomy in several Latin American jurisdictions in addition to the jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights has transformed and will likely continue to transform the situation.…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Coloniality of corporate social responsibility

Poesche¹

2020

International Journal of Discrimination and the Law

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The objective of this article is to make the case horizontally that the intertwined legal compliance and corporate social responsibility (CSR) abet enduring coloniality in settler colonial states. The focus is on Indigenous nations and settler colonial states in the Americas. There are three key contributions. First, the jurisprudential, managerial, philosophical and political foundations of CSR are of Occidental extraction therefore making CSR susceptible to being a tool of coloniality directed against Indigenous nations. Second, CSR is constrained by compliance with Occidental jurisprudence. Third, firms’ compliance with Indigenous nations’ cosmovisions can be best safeguarded by legal pluralism-based compliance as this entails court-imposed coercive enforcement. CSR is not part of the solution; CSR is part of the problem.

show abstract

Misunderstanding the Ngen Kintuantü : a study from the legal pluralism of water rights in the conflict around Statkraft’s hydroelectric power plants on the Pilmaiquén River, Futawillimapu, Chile

Guerra-Schleef

2024

Legal Pluralism and Critical Social Analysis

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Una invitación al pluralismo legal

Cited by 3 publications

References 31 publications

Las intervenciones judiciales al arbitraje internacional en Colombia y la seguridad jurídica

Las intervenciones judiciales al arbitraje internacional en Colombia y la seguridad jurídica

Coloniality of corporate social responsibility

Misunderstanding the Ngen Kintuantü : a study from the legal pluralism of water rights in the conflict around Statkraft’s hydroelectric power plants on the Pilmaiquén River, Futawillimapu, Chile

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About