Turn up the Dial: System Dynamics Modeling of Resource Allocations toward Rural Water Supply Maintenance in East Africa

Abstract

Water stress is increasingly affecting hundreds of millions of people around the world. In East Africa, severe and persistent drought periods negatively impact health and livelihoods. Drought increases reliance on mechanized boreholes to extract groundwater. However, without adequate resource allocations, effective monitoring of borehole functionality, and reliable maintenance service, breakdown rates increase and downtimes last many months. Our study applies system dynamics modeling to investigate the effects of allocating resources to borehole maintenance and repair in the Afar Region in Ethiopia and Turkana County in Kenya. We inform model calibration with runtime and functionality estimates derived from sensors installed on 245 boreholes and apply sensitivity analyses varying budget allocations to optimize for functionality. We conclude that increasing the borehole repair and maintenance budgets in Turkana from the current 30% to 85% of available budgets could result in an additional 83 working boreholes and 95% functionality in 2030. In Afar, increasing maintenance budgets from 38% to 79% could result in functionality levels of 75% by 2030, well above currently projected levels of 54%.

Improving the Reliability of Water Service Delivery in Rural Kenya through Professionalized Maintenance: A System Dynamics Perspective

“…Ultimately, the challenge may be more political and institutional than financial in achieving coordination and compliance to longterm local goals over short-term project objectives, as previous research has demonstrated the potential value of reprioritizing funding allocations from the installation of new schemes toward maintenance provision. 3 The application of system dynamics modeling as a collaborative analysis tool provided a platform for emergent understanding of complex system behavior and may be particularly valuable for investigating the effects of sustainability interventions. The interviewees who informed model parameters experienced greater understanding of the complexity of rural water service delivery in Kitui over time, 29 as did the researchers who co-developed the model.…”

“…It is likely that stronger coordination with donor and NGO projects would close the funding gap. Ultimately, the challenge may be more political and institutional than financial in achieving coordination and compliance to long-term local goals over short-term project objectives, as previous research has demonstrated the potential value of reprioritizing funding allocations from the installation of new schemes toward maintenance provision …”

“…Decades of engineered water infrastructure solutions have improved water access in rural communities of low- and middle-income countries; however, poor planning and implementation strategies have left nearly a quarter of these water schemes nonfunctional . The complexity of achieving reliable rural water access stems from interconnections of technical, social, economic, and environmental factors all working in dynamic concert to promote or inhibit sustainable service delivery outcomes. − …”

Classification of water subscribers by machine learning algorithms

“…Throughout the world, water is a precious, essential and, regrettably, scarce resource (Dritsas & Trigka, 2023), and in recent years, water crisis and water scarcity have become important problems (Rahim et al, 2020); also climate change has added to this crisis (Libey et al, 2022) and has intensified drought in many parts of the world (Smith & Wang, 2008). One of the harmful consequences of drought is the reduction of the quantity and quality of water resources (Akbari et al, 2022; Babaei et al, 2013), which has a direct impact on the lives of all humans in all parts of the world.…”

Application of D-S Evidence Theory in Marine Environmental Security Posture Assessment

“…the Bayesian method has a complete theoretical basis and easy-to-understand mathematical properties, the prior and conditional probability are difficult to obtain in practical applications. Therefore, the method has great limitations [4].…”