The decay width of N (1535) → N η is as large as that of N (1535) → N π. This is in evident conflict with simple expectations based on flavor symmetry and phase space. Similarly, the decay width of Λ(1670) → Λ(1116)η is larger than predicted by flavor symmetry. In this work, we propose that the axial U (1)A anomaly is responsible for an enhanced coupling of (some) excited baryons to the η meson. We test this idea by including a new, chirally symmetric but U (1)A anomalous, term in an effective hadronic model describing baryons and their chiral partners in the mirror assignment. This term enhances the decay of the chiral partners into baryons and an η meson, such as N (1535) → N η. Moreover, a strong coupling of N (1535) to N η emerges (this is important for studies of η production processes). Our approach shows that N (1535) is predominantly the chiral partner of N (939), and Λ(1670) the chiral partner of Λ(1116). Finally, our formalism can be used to couple the pseudoscalar glueballG to baryons. We expect a large cross section for the reaction pp →G →pp (1535), which can be experimentally tested in the future PANDA experiment.