The View of Religious Officials on Organ Donation and Transplantation in the Zeytinburnu District of Istanbul

Abstract

One of the obstacles to organ donation and transplantation in Turkey is that of religious beliefs and, at this point, religious officials constitute a key aspect of this problem. Positive or negative viewpoints held by religious officials regarding organ donation and transplantation are influential in guiding the public. This descriptive study was conducted for the purpose of describing religious officials' viewpoints on this subject. To determine the opinions of 40 religious officials from among the imams and muezzins working in Zeytinburnu District Mufti (Religious Officials Superior) Station who participated in a normal meeting in April and who fully completed the survey. A 27-question survey form was used that consisted of open-ended and closed questions, 5 of which were on socio-demographic characteristics, 13 on viewpoints on organ donation and transplantation, and 9 on the Islamic viewpoint regarding organ donation and transplantation. For the analysis of the results, Student's t test and one-way ANOVA tests were used. It was found that all of the religious officials believed in the importance of organ donation, 80 % considered donating their organs, and 5 % had made an organ donation. Of the religious officials who had not donated organs, 35 % gave an answer that there was no specific reason and 27.5 % stated that they had never considered the subject. While the number of those stating that they would donate the organs of a close associate who had died, 77.5 % of them who did not want to donate gave as their reason the idea that if it were him, he would perhaps not want to give his organs after death. Of the religious officials questioned, 92.5 % asserted that the religion of Islam looked positively on organ donation and transplantation, 55 % stated that the knowledge of religious officials in the country was inadequate regarding this subject, and 65 % said that for interest in organ donation to increase, religious officials should make speeches and raise the issue with the public in conversations, meetings, and sermons. Fully 85 % asserted that for interest in organ donation in Turkey to increase, religious officials have to lead on the subject. Of those questioned, 52.5 % considered their knowledge on organ donation and transplantation to be adequate and that they had obtained 52.5 % of such information from seminars/conferences, 50 % from television/radio, and 45 % from Directorate of Religious Affairs publications. However, 40 % expressed that they did not know where organ donations were made. One reason for inadequate organ donation in Turkey is that of incorrect religious beliefs. Thus, it is necessary that informative efforts are made by the Directorate of Religious Affairs through in-house training programs, and that healthcare, religious, and legal officials work jointly to inform the public about organ donation, organ transplantation, and brain death. Additionally, religious officials should donate organs by the way of example and, to increase their sensitivity, healthcare professionals should g...

Organ donation and transplant: The Islamic perspective

“…The Imams had minimal knowledge about the organ donation program in the UK . The majority of Turkish religious leaders believed that organ donation was acceptable; however, a considerable number did not have adequate knowledge about the topic and many desired more information about transplantation and organ donation be made available to the public . When asked about possible reasons for insufficient organ donation among Muslims, Turkish religious officials cited insufficient information about donation and transplantation, religious beliefs, and inefficient coordination regarding organ transplantation .…”

Mitos sobre la donación de órganos en personal de salud, potenciales receptores y familiares de potenciales donantes en un hospital peruano: estudio cualitativo

“…Incluso cuando ninguna religión se opone a la donación y, por el contrario, la consideran un acto libre y de generosidad hacia el prójimo. Así, el temor a ser mutilado o no participar de la resurrección compromete la decisión de ser donante (7,9,26,27,28) .…”

Religious beliefs; Barrier or mainspring to organ donation

“…Primarily, we need to determine those parameters that truly play a role in the process of decision making for organ donation, and investigate the effective methods to promote the willingness of the population for applying this valuable life saving behavior in the society. Previous studies introduced several factors such as lack of information about organ donation, emotional and spiritual issues, cultural values, socioeconomic factors, and religious beliefs that compel individual and family members in order to reach a decision in donating an organ (2,3). But, unfortunately the proportion of population based studies considering this issue among diverse ethnic and cultural groups is scarce.…”