The use of proxies and proxy-reported measures: a report of the international society for quality of life research (ISOQOL) proxy task force

Abstract

Aims Proxy reports are often used when patients are unable to self-report. It is unclear how proxy measures are currently in use in adult health care and research settings. We aimed to describe how proxy reports are used in these settings, including the use of measures developed specifically for proxy reporting in adult health populations. Methods We systematically searched Medline, PsycINFO, PsycTESTS, CINAHL and EMBASE from database inception to February 2018. Search terms included a combination of terms for quality of life and health outcomes, proxy-reporters, and health condition terms. The data extracted included clinical context, the name of the proxy measure(s) used and other descriptive data. We determined whether the measures were developed specifically for proxy use or were existing measures adapted for proxy use. ResultsThe database search identified 17,677 possible articles, from which 14,098 abstracts were reviewed. Of these, 11,763 were excluded and 2335 articles were reviewed in full, with 880 included for data extraction. The most common clinical settings were dementia (30%), geriatrics (15%) and cancer (13%). A majority of articles (51%) were paired studies with proxy and patient responses for the same person on the same measure. Most paired studies (77%) were concordance studies comparing patient and proxy responses on these measures. Discussion Most published research using proxies has focused on proxy-patient concordance. Relatively few measures used in research with proxies were specifically developed for proxy use. Future work is needed to examine the performance of measures specifically developed for proxies. Systematic review registration PROSPERO No. CRD42018103179 Keywords Proxy measures • Proxy-reported outcomes • Outcome measures • Quality of life • Systematic review * Jessica K. Roydhouse

Incorporating Information From Proxies for Patient-Centered Outcomes in Adult and Pediatric Oncology Settings

“…Most research on proxy reports has focused on evaluating the similarity or concordance of proxy and patient reports. 14 In adult oncology, the correlation between proxy and patient responses has been higher for domains such as physical function or physical well-being than emotional function or emotional well-being, suggesting better agreement for more observable aspects of health. 15,16 On average, proxies reported worse physical and emotional health than patients did.…”

Key considerations to reduce or address respondent burden in patient-reported outcome (PRO) data collection

“…The need for clear guidance on proxy reporting has been noted in palliative care 86 , and there is some guidance for the use of self- or proxy reporting in children and adolescents 90 . Additional work is required to optimise the use of proxy-reported data 91 as well as adapt existing PROMs or develop new ones for people who have difficulties completing the currently available PROMs (e.g., develop versions with pictures, icons or emoticons).…”

Contrasting Views of Autism Spectrum Traits in Adults, Especially in Self-Reports vs. Informant-Reports for Women High in Autism Spectrum Traits

“…in dementia, terminal illness, etc. ), (Roydhouse et al, 2021 ). Also, in an expansive set of studies, discrepancy between child/adolescent self-reports and informant-reports about family relationships, victimization experiences, and other clinically relevant domains have been shown to predict clinical and behavioral outcomes independent of the scores themselves (e.g.…”