“…We note that Maurer et al, in their correspondence, 1 have raised some concerns about the preanalytical and analytical validation of the peptide YY (PYY) assay described in our paper ‘The postprandial secretion of peptide YY 1 –36 and 3 –36 in obesity is differentially increased after gastric bypass versus sleeve gastrectomy’ 2 . The validation and assay characteristics were not the primary objectives of the paper.…”