The relevance and impact of business schools: In search of a holistic view

Abstract

The degree to which business schools are relevant and impactful for society has been disputed. Critics that engage in the so-called 'relevance problem' have argued that business schools are preoccupied with academic rigour at the expense of practical relevance, resulting in a lack of societal impact. This systematic literature review synthesizes the fragmented body of knowledge pertaining to the relevance and impact of business schools. Appreciating the contributions of both research and education, this review offers a holistic view that acknowledges the multidimensional nature of business schools. Based on an analysis of 266 journal articles, we present the four main literature streams in this domain.We find limited evidence of cross-fertilisation between discussions of research and education. However, by acknowledging the contribution of applying a multidimensional lens to the study of business schools, we develop a holistic thematic framework that provides theoretical directions for the future. Using this, we demonstrate four avenues for advancing the business school literature. First, we emphasise the potential of an institutional logics perspective to viewing business schools. Second, we offer a novel proposal for understanding the bridge between research and education. Third, we emphasise the application of a value co-creation theoretical lens when considering how business schools engage with stakeholders in research and education. Finally, we propose an all-encompassing stakeholder-centric definition of relevant and impactful knowledge and advocate for this inclusive definition to conceptually bridge the fragmented discussions of research and education.

Varieties of Time in Business Sustainability Research: An Integrative Review and Research Agenda

“…For our integrative review, we included journals across 12 domains (i.e., Entrepreneurship and Small Business Management, General Management, Ethics, and Social Responsibility, Human Resource Management, and Employment Studies, Innovation, International Business and Area Studies, Management Development and Education, Organization Studies, Psychology [Organizational], Regional Studies, Planning and Environment, Sector Studies, Operation Management, Strategy ). Several recent integrative review studies have used the same selection procedure, for example, Gamble & Muñoz’s (2022) examination of value detraction among non-profit organizations, Redgrave et al’s (2022) review of the relevance and impact of business schools, and Thomas and Tee’s (2022) integrative conceptual framework on generativity. The categories included in the ABS AJG list cover most of the research spectrum conducted by scholars involved in schools of business, management, or economics (Gamble & Muñoz, 2022).…”

A Model of Lecturers Professional Development in Business School of Research Universities in the 21st Century

“…Kociatkiewicz et al [28] comment that the curriculum of the business school is seen as upholding capitalist relationships. However, business schools are often absorbed in academic rigour, potentially neglecting practical relevance and, consequently, diminishing societal impact [44].…”

“…There is significance in business schools emphasizing practical wisdom alongside providing scientific and technical expertise. Management education encompasses the development of applied sagacity, surpassing the mere dissemination of factual scientific information, proficiencies, and methodologies [44,49]. It has been suggested that a significant portion of the research conducted in business schools focuses excessively on scientific rigour while overlooking practical applicability, commonly referred to as the gap between rigour and relevance [44].…”

Revolutionizing Business and Marketing Education: The MECCDAL Model and a Case Study from the American Institute of Business Experience Design

“…However, these methods often lack a comprehensive, learner-centric approach to higher education. Despite the 1 Professor of Marketing, University of Lyon 2, France integration of various methodologies, research indicates that business colleges often neglect the holistic aspect of higher education (Redgrave, Grinevich, and Chao 2022). This neglect results in insufficient emotional, spiritual, and social development in learners, limited interdisciplinary learning opportunities, and inadequate emphasis on human relationships within the current educational paradigm.…”