For the proposed IsoDAR experiment in neutrino physics, a dedicated H + 2 ion source (MIST-1) was designed and built at MIT. The MIST-1 ion source is a filament-driven multicusp ion source, optimized for the production of H + 2 over protons and H + 3 . In this paper, we report the commissioning results of MIST-1 and first systematic measurements of beam current and beam composition as functions of gas load, discharge voltage, and discharge current. The commissioning setup includes a Faraday cup directly after the source (for total beam current measurements), a mass separator consisting of a dipole magnet, slits and another Faraday cup (for beam composition measurements), as well as a set of Allison emittance scanners (for beam quality measurements). Highlights of the results are total beam current densities as high as 40 mA/cm 2 and a H + 2 ion species fraction of up to 90 % in DC mode (non-pulsed). The measured emittances are well-reproduced in simulations and are low, as expected for this type of ion source. Thus, MIST-1 is well suited to inject beam into an RFQ for bunching and subsequent acceleration in a compact cyclotron.