The First Concussion Crisis: Head Injury and Evidence in Early American Football

Abstract

In the early 21st century, sports concussion has become a prominent public health problem, popularly labeled "The Concussion Crisis." Football-related concussion contributes much of the epidemiological burden and inspires much of the public awareness. Though often cast as a recent phenomenon, the crisis in fact began more than a century ago, as concussions were identified among footballers in the game's first decades. This early concussion crisis subsided-allowing the problem to proliferate-because work was done by football's supporters to reshape public acceptance of risk. They appealed to an American culture that permitted violence, shifted attention to reforms addressing more visible injuries, and legitimized football within morally reputable institutions. Meanwhile, changing demands on the medical profession made practitioners reluctant to take a definitive stance. Drawing on scientific journals, public newspapers, and personal letters of players and coaches, this history of the early crisis raises critical questions about solutions being negotiated at present.

On-field management and return-to-play in sports-related concussion in children: Are children managed appropriately?

“…Sports-related concussion has received growing media and scientific attention in recent years for its increasing incidence and possible short and long-term sequelae. 1 Children are particularly vulnerable with 65% of all sport-related head injuries presenting to US emergency departments (EDs) being in persons aged 5-18 years. 2 In Australia, the impact of concussion on the child and on the health sector is not well described, despite 63% of school-aged children participating in at least one organised sport outside school hours.…”

Premortem Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy Diagnoses in Professional Football

“…Starting in 2014, the FPHS 18 recruited former football players who had received compensation from any National Football League (NFL) team starting in 1960, when the league transitioned from soft leather to hard plastic helmets. 19 We explicitly considered active players ineligible. We obtained email and residential information for 16,089 eligible former players from the NFL Players Association.…”

Sports and Headaches

“…The first football concussion crisis occurred over 100 years ago when a significant number of concussions and deaths resulted in recommendations to outlaw the game or at least make it safer . After he was kicked and hit in the head in the Army‐Navy game of 1893 and a Navy doctor told him this could result in instant insanity or death, Reeves (later to be an admiral and “the father of carrier aviation”) invented the first football helmet (a moleskin hat with earflaps)…”