The effect of undergraduate students on district health services delivery in the Western Cape Province, South Africa

Abstract

Background. The quality of care, attitudes of staff and long-term recruitment of practitioners have been shown internationally to improve health services as a result of a health facility accepting students for teaching. This study aimed to develop further insight regarding the impact of undergraduate student involvement on district health services in South Africa to understand the issues in a resource-constrained environment. Objectives. To describe the effect of the placement of undergraduate students on service delivery, and to understand the health service and academic factors that influence this effect. Methods. A descriptive study, using qualitative methods, was undertaken in two rural sites where undergraduate health science students had been recently introduced. Potential respondents were identified to be interviewed on the basis of their positions in the health services, their degree of involvement with students and their knowledge of the health system. Results. Sixteen participants were interviewed, and described the effect of undergraduate students on service delivery in terms of a balance between the burden and benefit. Three pivotal issues, which could tip the balance in favour of one or the other, included the length of time of student rotations, seniority of the students and number of students allocated to a particular site. Overall, it would appear that the balance was marginally in favour of the benefit of student service delivery. Conclusion. Undergraduate students can add value to service delivery under certain conditions, but further research is needed to quantify this effect. This open-access article is distributed under Creative Commons licence CC-BY-NC 4.0. Afr J Health Professions Educ

Clinical education and training: Have we sufficiently shifted our paradigm?

“…Even though the main objective of clinical education and training, which involves placing students on varied clinical platforms, is to develop specific clinical competencies in students, the positive impact of having students on a specific clinical platform is reported on by Reid et al [11] This is an important aspect to consider in settings where human resources for health are limited.…”

Placement Architectures in Practice: An Exploration of Student Learning during Non-Traditional Work-Integrated Learning in Rural Communities

“…The TRPM placements were all undertaken in rural communities, defined as areas outside of major cities under the Modified Monash Model which characterises Australian geographic areas based on population and relative access to services [ 31 ]. Rural health student placements make an important contribution to WIL programmes internationally by boosting WIL numbers, servicing rural communities, contributing to students’ understanding of the complex relationship between socio-geographic location and health, and developing the future health workforce in these communities [ 32 , 33 , 34 ]. The TRPM placements focus on students working with specific population groups in a way that supports interprofessional learning opportunities and fosters respect for health consumers.…”

Editorial: Ushering in a new year and reaching out to the next generation of family doctors

“…A publication by members of the Collaboration for Health Equity through Education and Research (CHEER) concluded that undergraduate students can add benefit to health services if health professions educators plan their clinical rotations, with the proviso of recognising the pressures under which their clinical supervisors work to deliver services to patients. 6 Significantly, the presiding policy perspective includes a call to transform the training of graduates and to align curricula with the international focus on social accountability and universal health coverage. This may be achieved through various methods, such as enrolling medical officers for a postgraduate primary care diploma 7 , training family physicians to scale 8 , as well as embracing the Academy of Science of South Africa (ASSAf) recommendations for socially accountable education.…”