The effect of transmission bandwidth on diagnostic accuracy in remote fetal ultrasound scanning

Abstract

Six subspecialists with considerable experience in fetal ultrasound viewed a selection of pre-recorded ultrasound scans. Scans from 18 patients recorded on VHS video-tape were supplied from five centres in the UK and Ireland, each made on a high-resolution ultrasound machine by an experienced sonologist at a referral centre. Each observer viewed the scans on a large display monitor in an individual viewing booth. The scans were viewed in random order, at randomly selected bandwidths. Observers, who were blinded to both recording and bandwidth, assessed the technical quality on a five-point Likert scale. They also recorded their diagnosis. The six observers each carried out 32 viewing sessions, which gave a total of 192 viewings. There was no significant difference in the perceived technical quality of the scans between the two bandwidths used (P = 0.09). Of the 84 recordings transmitted at 1920 kbit/s, 71 (85%) were diagnosed correctly or 'half correctly' and 13 (15%) were misdiagnosed. Of the 95 recordings transmitted at 384 kbit/s, 66 (69%) were diagnosed correctly or 'half correctly' and 29 (31%) were misdiagnosed. This difference was significant (P = 0.03). The results indicate that although there were no perceived differences in technical quality between recordings transmitted at 384 or 1920 kbit/s, diagnostic accuracy was marginally worse at the lower bandwidth. This suggests that the higher bandwidth conveys more detail and information to the observer, which in turn enables more accurate diagnosis. However, further work is required before a definitive choice can be made about the optimum transmission bandwidth for remote fetal ultrasound studies.

Telemedicine: Technology mediated service relationship, encounter, or something else?

“…Thus, telemedicine introduces changes to the communication process between the doctor and patient that may in turn affect health outcomes if not recognized and managed. However, most prior telemedicine research in health related journals addresses either the quality of patient care as assessed by medical outcomes [e.g., [23][24][25], with limited insight regarding aspects of the service delivery system (e.g., see review by [26]), or focuses on specific technological attributes such as video quality [e.g., 27,28].…”

Real-time video transmission of ultrasound images to an iPhone

“…This results in degradation in the quality of the image, a drop in number of frames per second, a delay in transmission, or some combination of the above. Literature exists on technological advances, variable compression and bandwidth on their effect on real-time transmission of video [19][20][21][22][23].…”

Telemedicine services for two islands in the Bay of Naples

“…Doppler) were transmitted in realtime. Ultrasound radiologists have judged the transmission quality at 384 kbit/s satisfactory for diagnostic purposes 23,24 .…”