2024
|
Sign up to set email alerts
The effect of physical exercise interventions on insomnia: A systematic review and meta-analysis
Search citation statements
Order By: Relevance
Paper Sections
Select...
45
7
5
0
Citation Types
0
19
0
0
Year Published
Range
2024
20242026
2026Publication Types
Select...
54
1
Relationship
1
54
Authors
Journals
Cited by 55 publications
(19 citation statements)
References 52 publications
0
19
0
0
Order By: Relevance
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…All included studies used self-report sleep measures and open-label designs, and none was rated as low risk of bias, so subjective reporting bias and expectancy effects cannot be excluded. Given that exercise tends to improve subjective sleep parameters more than objective ones ( 7 ), the effect sizes reported here may overestimate the true treatment effect. These concerns are reflected in the GRADE rating of very low certainty.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 81%
“…Effect size variability arose more from differences among walking arms, outcome measures, or assessment time points within individual studies than from systematic differences in populations, countries, or intervention protocols across studies. Previous meta-analyses have typically reported only total I 2 without hierarchical decomposition ( 7–9 ) and therefore could not distinguish between these sources of heterogeneity. This finding has implications for future RCT design.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…All included studies used self-report sleep measures and open-label designs, and none was rated as low risk of bias, so subjective reporting bias and expectancy effects cannot be excluded. Given that exercise tends to improve subjective sleep parameters more than objective ones ( 7 ), the effect sizes reported here may overestimate the true treatment effect. These concerns are reflected in the GRADE rating of very low certainty.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 81%
“…Effect size variability arose more from differences among walking arms, outcome measures, or assessment time points within individual studies than from systematic differences in populations, countries, or intervention protocols across studies. Previous meta-analyses have typically reported only total I 2 without hierarchical decomposition ( 7–9 ) and therefore could not distinguish between these sources of heterogeneity. This finding has implications for future RCT design.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…While a recent NMA by Riedel et al (2024) confirmed that exercise improves sleep in individuals with insomnia (SMD = 0.90 for subjective outcomes), and earlier reviews ( Hasan et al, 2022 ) have highlighted the general benefits of physical activity, none provide a comparative effectiveness ranking across specific exercise modalities—particularly in sedentary adults without clinical insomnia, a population in which optimal intervention selection remains unclear. Our NMA provides preliminary evidence for a modality-specific hierarchy that may inform tailored exercise approaches in this population.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…During the sanatorium stay, all participants attended exercise sessions as well as physical and balneological treatments. Previous reports indicate that physical activity and exercise have positive effects on sleep quality, particularly by reducing sleep onset latency and improving sleep efficiency and continuity [31][32][33]. Several mechanisms may underlie exercise-mediated improvements in insomnia, including neurotransmitter synthesis and action, activation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, anti-inflammatory effects, thermoregulatory responses, as well as stress reduction and mood improvement [34,35].…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…All included studies used self-report sleep measures and open-label designs, and none was rated as low risk of bias, so subjective reporting bias and expectancy effects cannot be excluded. Given that exercise tends to improve subjective sleep parameters more than objective ones ( 7 ), the effect sizes reported here may overestimate the true treatment effect. These concerns are reflected in the GRADE rating of very low certainty.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 81%
“…Effect size variability arose more from differences among walking arms, outcome measures, or assessment time points within individual studies than from systematic differences in populations, countries, or intervention protocols across studies. Previous meta-analyses have typically reported only total I 2 without hierarchical decomposition ( 7–9 ) and therefore could not distinguish between these sources of heterogeneity. This finding has implications for future RCT design.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…While a recent NMA by Riedel et al (2024) confirmed that exercise improves sleep in individuals with insomnia (SMD = 0.90 for subjective outcomes), and earlier reviews ( Hasan et al, 2022 ) have highlighted the general benefits of physical activity, none provide a comparative effectiveness ranking across specific exercise modalities—particularly in sedentary adults without clinical insomnia, a population in which optimal intervention selection remains unclear. Our NMA provides preliminary evidence for a modality-specific hierarchy that may inform tailored exercise approaches in this population.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…During the sanatorium stay, all participants attended exercise sessions as well as physical and balneological treatments. Previous reports indicate that physical activity and exercise have positive effects on sleep quality, particularly by reducing sleep onset latency and improving sleep efficiency and continuity [31][32][33]. Several mechanisms may underlie exercise-mediated improvements in insomnia, including neurotransmitter synthesis and action, activation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, anti-inflammatory effects, thermoregulatory responses, as well as stress reduction and mood improvement [34,35].…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…All included studies used self-report sleep measures and open-label designs, and none was rated as low risk of bias, so subjective reporting bias and expectancy effects cannot be excluded. Given that exercise tends to improve subjective sleep parameters more than objective ones ( 7 ), the effect sizes reported here may overestimate the true treatment effect. These concerns are reflected in the GRADE rating of very low certainty.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 81%
“…Effect size variability arose more from differences among walking arms, outcome measures, or assessment time points within individual studies than from systematic differences in populations, countries, or intervention protocols across studies. Previous meta-analyses have typically reported only total I 2 without hierarchical decomposition ( 7–9 ) and therefore could not distinguish between these sources of heterogeneity. This finding has implications for future RCT design.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…While a recent NMA by Riedel et al (2024) confirmed that exercise improves sleep in individuals with insomnia (SMD = 0.90 for subjective outcomes), and earlier reviews ( Hasan et al, 2022 ) have highlighted the general benefits of physical activity, none provide a comparative effectiveness ranking across specific exercise modalities—particularly in sedentary adults without clinical insomnia, a population in which optimal intervention selection remains unclear. Our NMA provides preliminary evidence for a modality-specific hierarchy that may inform tailored exercise approaches in this population.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…During the sanatorium stay, all participants attended exercise sessions as well as physical and balneological treatments. Previous reports indicate that physical activity and exercise have positive effects on sleep quality, particularly by reducing sleep onset latency and improving sleep efficiency and continuity [31][32][33]. Several mechanisms may underlie exercise-mediated improvements in insomnia, including neurotransmitter synthesis and action, activation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, anti-inflammatory effects, thermoregulatory responses, as well as stress reduction and mood improvement [34,35].…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract