The Determinants of Gender Equity in India: Examining Dyson and Moore's Thesis with New Data

Abstract

In revisiting the influential Dyson and Moore (1983) hypothesis as to why women in South India enjoy relatively more agency than in the North, we conducted an econometric analysis of the determinants of women's mobility and decisionmaking authority. Data for the study come from a household data survey carried out in the Northern state of Uttar Pradesh and in the Southern state of Karnataka in 1995. We find that cross-cousin and uncle-niece marriage is more prevalent in Karnataka as expected. Contrary to Dyson and Moore, however, by 1995 a majority of communities in both North and South practiced village exogamy, and dowries in the two regions were of similar size. Reduced-form, multivariate regressions show that cultural factors affect women's autonomy in ways not earlier predicted. The impact of village exogamy is mixed rather than negative, while that of consanguinity is strongly negative rather than positive as Dyson and Moore surmised. These authors correctly identified the negative effect purdah has on female mobility. Consistent with economic theory, our data show that higher wages for women consistently improve their mobility and authority, while higher male wages decrease them. Improvements in infrastructure-particularly the presence of street lights and schools in the village-are associated with increased women's agency. We conclude, therefore, that economic factors, state action, and restrictions on mobility seem more powerful than kinship structures as explanations of differences in female autonomy between North and South India. Copyright 2004 The Population Council, Inc..

Influence of mothers-in-law on young couples’ family planning decisions in rural India

“…The findings support the empirical analysis of Rahman & Rao in 2004, that women's autonomy is not solely a reflection of kinship structures. 21 Public services such as family planning may have an important, transformative effect on familial power relations, making it possible for young couples to make autonomous choices about spacing children.…”

Excess male chronic energy deficiency among adolescents: a cross-sectional study in the context of patrilineal and matrilineal societies in Northeast India

“…On the contrary, girls aged below 3 y were more likely than boys to be underweight and stunted in the South than in the North. In addition, it has been suggested that economic and political factors, including political will, are more important than kinship structures in patterning gender differences between North and South India (Rahman & Rao, 2004).…”

Measuring the Effect of a Community-Level Program on Women's Empowerment Outcomes: Evidence from India

“…Hashemi, Schuler and Riley, 1996 find that physical mobility improves the degree of control over microcredit loans, since it reflects a woman's access to outside employment opportunities. A study of the determinants of female autonomy in India finds that a better-educated woman has greater bargaining power, as measured by physical mobility and say in household resource allocation, through the channel of increased information (Rahman and Rao, 2004). The same study also finds culture, as measured by state fixed-effects, to significantly increase bargaining power despite controlling for religion and caste.…”

“…Another section of the literature finds that a woman's access to employment outside the house increases her household bargaining power (for a study in Bangladesh, see Anderson and Eswaran, 2009; for a study in India, see Rahman and Rao, 2004). The ownership of assets, in particular, is one important way through which access to employment helps empower women in developing countries (for example, see Agarwal, 2001, for evidence from India).…”

“…Women with a more equal spousal age ratio, greater access to outside employment or a high level of political participation are also likely to have greater bargaining power. Thus, the indicators of a high level of empowerment include (1) access to outside employment, (2) physical mobility, and (3) political participation (Anderson and Eswaran, 2009;Hashemi, Schuler and Riley, 1996;Rahman and Rao, 2004). The corresponding dependent variables we use to reflect high levels of female autonomy are (1) the ownership of identification cards for the national government's rural employment guarantee scheme, which proxies for access to outside employment, (2) the ability to leave the household without permission, which reflects physical mobility, and (3) participation in weekly village council meetings, which measures political participation.…”