The collaborative effect of scientific meetings: A study of the International Milk Genomics Consortium

Abstract

Collaboration among scientists has a major influence on scientific progress. Such collaboration often results from scientific meetings, where scientists gather to present and discuss their research and to meet potential collaborators. However, most scientific meetings have inherent biases, such as the availability of research funding or the selection bias of professional societies that make it difficult to study the effect of the meeting per se on scientific productivity. To evaluate the effects of scientific meetings on collaboration and progress independent of these biases, we conducted a study of the annual symposia held by the International Milk Genomics Consortium (IMGC) over a 12-year period. In our study, we conducted permutation testing to analyze the effectiveness of the IMGC in facilitating collaboration and productivity in a community of milk scientists who were meeting attendees relative to non-attendees. Using the number of co-authorships on published papers as a measure of collaboration, our analysis revealed that scientists who attended the symposium were associated with more collaboration than were scientists who did not attend. Furthermore, we evaluated the scientific progress of consortium attendees by analyzing publication rate and article impact. We found that IMGC attendees, in addition to being more collaborative, were also more productive and influential than were non-attendees who published in the same field. The results of our study suggest that the annual symposium encouraged interactions among disparate scientists and increased research productivity, exemplifying the positive effect of scientific meetings on both collaboration and progress.

Heteroptera research in Latin America and the Caribbean (Insecta, Hemiptera): status and perspectives in the 21st century

“…The establishment of periodical reunions focused on Heteroptera could have influenced the researcher's community collaboration networks (i.e., IHS meetings and South American Workshops). Scientific meetings positively affect DIMITRI FORERO et al Cienc (2024) 96(1) e20230218 13 | 22 the production of papers and the number of coauthorships by encouraging interaction among colleagues (Kwok et al 2018). From 1998 to date, LAC Heteropterists met in seven Quadrennial Meetings of the International Heteropterists' Society (IHS) and five South American Heteroptera Workshops, besides non-specific broad entomological or zoological events that often take place in South America, such as Argentinean, Brazilian, Colombian, and Latin American congresses of Entomology.…”

Milk: A Scientific Model for Diet and Health Research in the 21st Century

“…The challenge is to identify and annotate genes associated with lactation. The goals for lactation genomics were propelled by a diverse group of scientists participating with the International Milk Genomics Consortium (5). The diversity of lactation across mammalia is an important asset, so the goal of the IMGC was to assemble a variety of entire genomes from marsupials to humans (6).…”

Goals in Nutrition Science 2020-2025

“…The big job of annotating those components for their functions is an aspirational goal for all of life science in part because of the breadth of discoveries to date that attest to the “genius” of lactation evolution. A view of the discoveries related to the macronutrients of milk make a compelling case for breast milk as the gold mine of life science research ( 185 ). Protein is not just providing amino acids.…”