The Challenges of Governing Urban Food Production across Four European City‐Regions: Identity, Sustainability and Governance

Abstract

The development of food production in cities has raised some important questions about the governance of these activities and the role of city-regions. In this paper through four European case studies-Bristol (UK), Ghent (Belgium), Vigo (Spain), and Zurich (Switzerland) -we consider the ways in which food is governed at the city level. Our case studies demonstrate the role played by citizens in urban food and the challenges this brings to city-region governance. Through horizontal networking, being inspirational to other cities and citizens, communicating their demands and successes very clearly, urban food activists have raised significant questions about how cities are governed. Using the creation of localized identities, which are inclusive and embracing but rooted in their city, these food activists are looking to a future controlled by a democratic impulse rather than the technocracy of professional city managers. This paper uses a range of Weberian influenced theory to explore the topic of urban agriculture not as one simply about environmental performance but of the construction of new civic identities.

El futuro del sistema agroalimentario de la Región Metropolitana de Buenos Aires: un ejercicio de prospectiva territorial

“…Sumado a esto, sistemas de comercialización de mayor intermediación redundan en mayores costos, aumento del precio de los alimentos y en menores oportunidades de capitalización para los productores. Por todo esto, promover canales cortos de comercialización, como parte importante de circuitos cortos de abastecimiento, representa una manera de apuntalar y promover las producciones de cercanía y su aporte a la sostenibilidad de las ciudades (Jarosz, 2008;Guiomar, 2011;Aubry y Kebir, 2013;Palacios-Argüello, Morganti y Gonzalez-Feliu, 2017;Dubois, 2018;Grando, Carey, Hegger, Jahrl y Ortolani, 2018), así como un empoderamiento de la comunidad que se afianza en una relación más directa entre productores y consumidores (Reed et al, 2018).…”

Socially-Inclusive Development and Value Creation: How a Composting Project in Galicia (Spain) ‘Hit the Rocks’

“…Bock argues that social innovation is 'characterized by processes of co-design or co-construction and collaboration with society' (ibid p. 58). In so doing Bock emphasizes the importance of social inclusion and the need for changes in politics and governance, that will allow new organizational forms, initiated by local actors, in order to approach challenges from a place-based development perspective rather having them treated as discrete sectoral policy issues (see also [12,37,[40][41][42][43]). Such changes can be perceived as disruptive to existing practices, since they envisage a system that is configured in a fundamentally different way.…”

The ‘Covid-Trigger’: New Light on Urban Agriculture and Systemic Approach to Urbanism to Co-Create a Sustainable Lisbon

“…Sustainable food system: Moscatelli et al ( 2016 ); Saavedra Cardoso et al ( 2017 ); Reed et al ( 2018 ); Feagan ( 2007 ); Horst et al ( 2017 ); Nogeire-McRae et al ( 2018 ); Deakin et al ( 2016 ); Marsden and Sonnino ( 2012 ); Turner ( 2011 ); Role of food in re-imagining the city: Marat-Mendes and Borges ( 2019 )…”