Domestic animal embryonic stem cells are of potentially big value in transgenic research and studies of lineage commitment and development. Unfortunately, despite many efforts, validated embryonic stem cell lines in species other than mice and primates are yet to be isolated. Here we review some factors that might help to explain why derivation of domestic animal embryonic stem cells is still unsuccessful.
Keywords Embryonic stem cells . Domestic speciesSince the first embryonic stem cell lines isolation from mouse embryos in 1981 [1, 2] the number of published articles dealing with these unique cells has steadily increased ( Fig. 1. Pubmed citations dated on January 1981-December 2008). The rise in the number of publications can be taken as a reflection of the interest aroused by these cells due to their unique biological properties and numerous applications.Stem cells derived from early embryos (Embryonic Stem Cells; ESC) are cultured cell lines that can be clonally propagated and maintained in culture indefinitely, while their ability to differentiate in vitro or in vivo into derivatives of all three germ layers remains preserved. Thus, ESC can contribute to form all tissues and organs, including germ cells. These singular traits have made ESC a useful tool for studying mammalian development, nuclear reprogramming, and cell lineage commitment and differentiation.Manipulation of ESC by homologous recombination is highly efficient [3], which provides a route for the precise modification of the animal genome by gene targeting. Currently, genetically modified mice are routinely produced by embryonic stem cell technology [4]. Transgenic mice are essential tools in the understanding of functional genomics, mammalian physiology and as animal models for a number of human diseases.Several animal reproductive biology research initiatives have envisaged the production of gene-targeted farm animals for improving productive traits and disease resistance and as models for human diseases. Such farm species would not show some of the limitations of the mouse model i.e. short life span or a physiology and anatomy very different from humans. Unfortunately, contrary to mice and primates, a key barrier to genetic modification in livestock has been the failure to establish embryonic stem cell lines from domestic species, which remains as a multi-faceted challenge. As pointed-out within several recent reviews [5][6][7][8][9], progress in ESC will arise from research focusing on the understanding of species-specific mechanisms that maintain pluripotency; identification of appropriate stem cell markers; and optimization of culture conditions.The existence of significant morphological and functional similarities between ESC from very different species [10,11] might have led researchers to an inappropriate, direct application on farm species of specific conditions used to isolate and maintain ESC from mice and humans. As a result of this misconception, and provided that important differences have also been observed [11], we n...