Teaching Atraumatic Restorative Treatment in U.S. Dental Schools: A Survey of Predoctoral Pediatric Dentistry Program Directors

Abstract

The International Dental Federation and World Health Organization have promoted the use of Atraumatic Restorative Treatment (ART) in modern clinical settings worldwide. In the United States, the practice of ART is not believed to be widely used, which may be a result of little attention given to ART training in predoctoral pediatric dentistry curricula in U.S. dental schools. This study investigated the extent of clinical and didactic instruction on ART provided in U.S. dental schools by surveying the predoctoral pediatric dentistry programs in 2010. Of the ifty-seven directors asked to complete the survey, forty-four responded for a response rate of 77 percent. Of these forty-four programs, 66 percent reported providing clinical training on ART, though only 14 percent provide this training often or very often. The types of ART training provided often or very often included interim treatment (18 percent) and single-surface cavities (14 percent) in primary teeth. However, ART was said to be rarely taught as a deinitive treatment in permanent teeth (2 percent). Attitude was a major predictor, for clinical training provided and using professional guidelines in treatment decisions were associated with a positive attitude towards ART. These predoctoral pediatric dentistry programs used ART mainly in primary, anterior, and single-surface cavities and as interim treatment. As ART increases access of children to dental care, the incorporation of the ART approach into the curricula of U.S. dental schools should be facilitated by professional organizations.Dr. Kateeb is Assistant Professor,

Teaching Silver Diamine Fluoride in U.S. Dental Schools’ Predoctoral Curricula

“…Surveys of dental professionals have found that professional guidelines, or the lack thereof, are an important factor in selecting treatment modalities 28 – 30 . Even though SDF is only approved by the FDA for dentin hypersensitivity, the findings of our study showed that the most popular indications being taught for SDF were arresting caries in primary teeth and arresting root caries.…”

“…This process often takes decades. Previous studies have shown that clinicians can take up to 15 years to substantially change the way they practice even when provided with sound information 24 , 27 , 28 , 33 , 34 . Moreover, new materials take years of research to gain a strong enough body of work to justify their addition to an evidence‐based dental curriculum.…”

WHO Global Consultation on Public Health Intervention against Early Childhood Caries

“…It was considered a “patient‐friendly” procedure . In addition to ART, an interim version of ART called the interim therapeutic restoration (ITR), which is almost identical to ART with the exception of proposed subsequent clinical intervention, can be provided prior to the definitive restoration . Finally, where resources allow, cavities in molars may be treated using the Hall technique.…”

Microscopic evaluation of rotatory and handle caries removal on glass ionomer cement/dentin interface

“…Moreover, this technique can be performed in faster clinical sessions and with reduced cost of treatment being recommended by the International Dental Federation and World Health Organization in worldwide 16 . Researches showed that the longevity of ART restorations in primary teeth are similar from those produced using traditional methods using either amalgam or resin composite 17,18 .…”