Switching benefits and costs in the Irish health insurance market: an analysis of consumer surveys

Abstract

Relatively little analysis has taken place internationally on the consumer-reported benefits and costs to switching insurer in multi-payer health insurance markets. Ideally, consumers should be willing to switch out of consideration for price and quality and switching should be able to take place without incurring significant switching costs. Costs to switching come in many forms and understanding the nature of these costs is necessary if policy interventions to improve market competition are to be successful. This study utilises data from consumer surveys of the Irish health insurance market collected between 2009 and 2013 (N [Formula: see text] 1703) to examine consumer-reported benefits and costs to switching insurer. Probit regression models are specified to examine the relationship between consumer characteristics and reported switching costs, and switching behaviour, respectively. Overall evidence suggests that switchers in the Irish market mainly did so out of consideration for price. Transaction cost was the most common switching cost identified, reported by just under 1 in 7 non-switchers. Psychological switching costs may also be impacting behaviour. Moreover, high-risk individuals were more likely to experience switching costs and this was reflected in actual switching behaviour. A recent information campaign launched by the market regulator may prove beneficial in reducing perceived transaction costs in the market, however, a more focused campaign aimed at high-risk consumers may be necessary to reduce inequalities. Policy-makers should also consider the impact insurer behaviour may have on decision-making.

Insights from behavioral economics for policymakers of choice‐based health insurance markets: A scoping review

“…Low income (Swartz & Graves, 2014) Quality of plan choice Smart defaults (Van Winssen et al, 2016) Endowment effect (2) It shows up in the form of increased loyalty to doctors, the network of hospitals, and existing health plan providers, making it thereby less likely that individuals would switch plans even if it is beneficial for them (Boonen et al, 2011;Keegan et al, 2019). Framing effect (3) When consumers mentally frame the health insurance decision as a "certain loss of premiums in return for an uncertain gain from coverage," they may not purchase health insurance (Baicker et al, 2012;Johnson et al, 1993;M.…”

The Management and Administrative Practices Resulting in the Exit of Nurses from the Irish Healthcare System – a Review

“…There are various components of this plan including 'Acute Care', 'Patient Safety', 'Health and Brexit' and 'Nursing and Midwifery' among others (Department of Health, 2016). The significant interest shown by the government in the health services sector in recent years may lead to major changes and aims to provide universal healthcare in Ireland (Keegan et al, 2019). The focus has now moved to consolidation and improved quality and efficiency.…”