A distinction
between the homogeneous and heterogeneous catalytic
mechanisms of a myriad of Pd catalytic systems for the Suzuki-Miyaura
reaction has been made based on soluble metal complexes or heterogenized
Pd compounds. To date, hypotheses that concern whether the reaction
proceeds in the solution phase or on the surface of solid particles,
including nanosized ones, have been based on experimental results
obtained under different reaction conditions. Moreover, convincing
evidence was obtained for reactions proceeding simultaneously through
homogeneous and heterogeneous catalytic mechanisms. However, most
of the experimental evidence was obtained for relatively reactive
aryl bromides and aryl iodides, while insufficient data exists for
nonreactive aryl chlorides to make any well-grounded conclusions regarding
the homogeneous or heterogeneous nature of the active species. Here,
we report the use of “ligand-free” conditions, which
excludes the need to add strong organic ligands, such as phosphines,
amines, and carbenes, for the activation of aryl chlorides in the
Suzuki-Miyaura reaction. The results suggest that the reaction proceeds
in the solution phase through a homogeneous mechanism even when heterogeneous
precursors are used. The main reason for this conclusion is the independence
of the reaction differential selectivity under the competition of
two aryl chlorides or two arylboronic acids, which is based on numerous
parameters that only influence the nature of the possible heterogeneous
Pd forms when the homogeneous mechanism is realized.