Decarboxylation reactions
from comparable thiamin diphosphate-
and thiamin-derived adducts of p-(halomethyl)benzoylformic
acids in enzymic and non-enzymic reactions, respectively, reveal critical
distinctions in otherwise similar Breslow intermediates. The ratio
of protonation to chloride elimination from the Breslow intermediate
is 102-fold greater in the enzymic process. This is consistent
with a lower intrinsic barrier to proton transfer on the enzyme, implicating
formation of a localized tetrahedral (sp3) carbanion that
is formed as CO2 is produced. In contrast, slower protonation
in solution of the decarboxylated intermediate is consistent with
formation of a delocalized planar carbanionic enol/enamine. The proposed
structural and reactive character of the enzymic Breslow intermediate
is consistent with Warshel’s general theory of enzymic catalysis,
structural characterization of related intermediates, and the lower
kinetic barrier in reactions that occur without changes in hybridization.