Significance of intra-fractional motion for pancreatic patients treated with charged particles

Abstract

BackgroundUncertainties associated with the delivery of treatment to moving organs might compromise the accuracy of treatment. This study explores the impact of intra-fractional anatomical changes in pancreatic patients treated with charged particles delivered using a scanning beam. The aim of this paper is to define the potential source of uncertainties, quantify their effect, and to define clinically feasible strategies to reduce them.MethodsThe study included 14 patients treated at our facility with charged particles (protons or 12C) using intensity modulated particle therapy (IMPT). Treatment plans were optimized using the Treatment Planning System (TPS) Syngo® RT Planning. The pre-treatment dose distribution under motion (4D) was simulated using the TPS TRiP4D and the dose delivered for some of the treatment fractions was reconstructed. The volume receiving at least 95% of the prescribed dose (V95CTV) and the target dose homogeneity were evaluated. The results from the 4D dose calculations were compared with dose distributions in the static case and its variation correlated with the internal motion amplitude and plan modulation, through the Pearson correlation coefficient, as well the significant p-value. The concept of the modulation index (MI) was introduced to assess the degree of modulation of IMPT plans, through the quantification of intensity gradients between neighboring pencil beams.ResultsThe induced breathing motion together with dynamic beam delivery results in an interplay effect, which affects the homogeneity and target coverage of the dose distribution. This effect is stronger (∆V95CTV > 10%) for patients with tumor motion amplitude above 5 mm and a highly modulated dose distribution between and within fields. The MI combined with the internal motion amplitude is shown to correlate with the target dose degradation and a lack of plan robustness against range and positioning uncertainties.ConclusionsUnder internal motion the use of inhomogeneous plans results in a decrease in the dose homogeneity and target coverage of dose distributions in comparison to the static case. Plan robustness can be improved by using multiple beams and avoiding beam entrance directions susceptible to density changes. 4D dose calculations support the selection of the most suitable plan for the specific patient’s anatomy.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s13014-018-1060-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Comparison of different treatment planning approaches for intensity-modulated proton therapy with simultaneous integrated boost for pancreatic cancer

“…Hence, the intrafractional movement of the target and the OARs could not be considered although this is an important issue in proton therapy. Breathing can result in undesirable over- and undershooting in target volumes (interplay effect) or even in increased dose to the normal tissue [ 35 , 36 ]. Using dose escalation approaches, the impact of intra- as well as interfractional organ motion is of highly clinical relevance.…”

Impact of interfractional anatomical variation and setup correction methods on interfractional dose variation in IMPT and VMAT plans for pancreatic cancer patients: A planning study

“…has since become a commonly used beam angle in two-field IMPT planning. 19 The RPOL plan was designed to add a third beam F I G . 3.…”

Validation of a model for physical dose variations in irregularly moving targets treated with carbon ion beams

“…The variability of breathing induced motion has been reported to be significant . This is a critical issue in particle therapy, as it introduces uncertainty in target localization and tissue density within the beam path with respect to the planning scenario.…”