Rurality as Concordance: Mental Health Service Delivery for Rural Survivors of Intimate Partner Violence

Abstract

This manuscript examines how a shared sociospatial or “rural” identity may uniquely facilitate mental health care delivery. In particular, we consider the significant but largely unexplored role that domestic violence center staff, whom we term “Reputational Provider-Experts” or RPEs, play in addressing the mental health needs of rural women who have experienced intimate partner violence. Using data collected through semi-structured individual and focus group interviews with RPEs across 12 counties and four tribal reservations in northern Wisconsin ( N = 15), we detail the sociospatial commonalities that enable RPEs to provide trusted, sustained mental health support to rural women. Because these advocates are rural community members whose approach implicitly appeals to local norms and values, we argue that they represent rurally concordant providers. In this way, rurality emerges as a meaningful and novel form of patient-provider concordance, one with critical relevance to addressing the rural mental health crisis in the United States.

“It Is Here We Are Loved”: Rural Place Attachment in Active Judging and Access to Justice

“…Elsewhere in the survey, we evaluated the extent to which litigants associate different kinds of "concordance," or shared demographic attributes between the judge and litigant, with fairness and just outcomes (Statz, Billings, and Wolf 2021). At the time of writing, 76 percent of surveyed litigants believe that, if the judge and the party before them are from the same place, the judge is better able to understand the person's experience and make a fair decision.…”

How Cultural Capital Shapes Mental Health Care Seeking in College

“…Previous researchers document the underutilization of mental health services among communities of color, men and boys, young people, rural residents, and people in lower socioeconomic positions (Biddle et al 2007; Eisenberg et al 2007; Lindsey et al 2010; Neighbors et al 2007; Stewart et al 2015). Structural barriers and a lack of culturally appropriate care contribute to these disparities (Williams, Rosen, and Kanter 2019), but sociocultural barriers are also partly responsible for these disparities in mental health care seeking (Horwitz et al 2020; Statz et al, 2021). Indeed, the literature on mental illness stigma demonstrates that stigma is a context-dependent social process that remains one of the most cited barriers to seeking mental health care (Clement et al 2015; Gaddis, Ramirez, and Hernandez 2018, 2020; Horwitz et al 2020; Pescosolido and Martin 2015; Pietrzak et al 2009).…”