The hydrolysis and transesterification of RNA are catalyzed by a variety of metal ions, metal complexes,
metalloenzymes, and ribozymes. These reactions are of fundamental biochemical importance. However, the role
that metal ions play in RNA hydrolysis is not completely understood. We previously showed that aqueous Cu(II)
terpyridine (Cutrpy) is effective for both transesterification and hydrolysis of RNA, and we harnessed this reactivity
by constructing ribozyme mimics that employ terpyridyl Cu(II) in their active sites. Here we report a detailed
kinetic study of the hydrolysis of adenosine-2‘,3‘-cyclic monophosphate (cAMP) by Cutrpy. The reaction is
established to be first-order in Cutrpy and first-order in substrate. Catalytic turnover is observed, although product
inhibition occurs. Chloride ion also inhibits the reaction, which indicates the disadvantage of using NaCl as an
ionic strength buffer in related studies. The pH−rate profile is sigmoidal and implicates the hydroxide form of
the catalyst, CutrpyOH+, as the active species. Isotope effects were used to determine whether the metal hydroxide
acts as a nucleophile or a base. The solvent deuterium kinetic isotope effect, k
H/k
D, was measured to be 1.0 ± 0.1
after considering equilibrium isotope effects. To assist the mechanistic interpretation of the measured isotope
effects, the fractionation factors for a dianionic phosphorane transition state (methyl phosphate dianion) and
hydroxide were evaluated by ab initio quantum chemical calculations. Considering the calculated results along
with the relevant experimental fractionation factors, isotope effects were predicted for three overall mechanisms:
nucleophilic catalysis, general base catalysis, and specific base/general acid catalysis. We conclude that CutrpyOH+
acts as a nucleophilic catalyst in the hydrolysis of cAMP. This contrasts with the behavior of CutrpyOH+ as a
base catalyst in the transesterification of RNA.