Resilience of the primary health care system – German primary care practitioners’ perspectives during the early COVID-19 pandemic

Abstract

Background Primary care is a relevant pillar in managing not only individual, but also societal medical crises. The COVID-19 pandemic has demanded a rapid response from primary care with interventions in the health care system. The aim of this paper was to explore the responses of primary care practitioners (PCP) during the early COVID-19 pandemic and to analyze these with a view on the resilience of the primary health care system from the PCPs perspective. Methods Shortly after the first COVID-19 wave (July—October 2020) n = 39, semi-structured telephone interviews were conducted with PCP in practices and at Corona contact points (CCP) in Baden-Wuerttemberg (Germany). Qualitative content analysis was applied, and the evolved categories were related to in a framework for resilience. Results Primary care had an overall strong ability to adapt and show resilience, albeit with wide variance in speed and scope of the responses. When coping with uncertainty, the reasons given by PCPs in favor of opening a CCP mainly involved intrinsic motivation and self-initiative; the reasons against doing so were i.e. the lack of personal protective equipment, problems with space, and worries about organizational burden. A strong association existed between the establishment of a CCP and the use of resources (i.e. existing networks, personal protective equipment, exercising an office of professional political function). Our study predominantly found adaptive aspects for measures taken at medical practices and transformative aspects for setting up outpatient infection centers. PCPs played an important role in the coordination process (i.e. actively transferring knowledge, integration in crisis management teams, inclusion in regional strategic efforts) reaching a high level in the dimensions knowledge and legitimacy. The dimension interdependence repeatedly came into focus (i.e. working with stakeholders to open CCP, interacting among different types of primary care facilities, intersectoral interfaces). A need for regional capacity planning was visible at the time of the interviews. Conclusions The results can be used for practical and research-based institutional and capacity planning, for developing resilience in primary care and for augmentation by perspectives from other stakeholders in the primary health care system.

Differences between Rural and Urban Practices in the Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic: Outcomes from the PRICOV-19 Study in 38 Countries

“…The degree of changes adopted by GP practices across countries indicates a strong ability to adapt, as confirmed in other studies [ 30 ]. However, as our data also showed, there was great variability in the speed and scope of the responses to the impact of COVID-19 in the practices, indicating potentially variable standards and quality of care [ 31 ].…”

Experience and views of primary care physicians involved in reorganisation of care in family medicine practices during COVID-19 pandemic: A qualitative study from Slovenia

“…Other studies reported various organisational adjustments to separate infectious from non-infectious patients [ 4 ]. Mainly, this occurred at the level of individual practices [ 12 ]. In Slovenia, this occurred at the level of PCHCs and/or an administrative region level [ 13 ].…”

Let's talk about it: the impact of nurses' implicit voice theories on individual agility and quality of care

“…These factors create a highly uncertain operational environment for healthcare providers, which has been amplified during the Covid-19 pandemic, where healthcare systems around the world have had to adapt quickly by re-allocating care capacity to face the large numbers of patients battling Covid-19 (Rennert-May et al. , 2021; Stengel et al. , 2022).…”

“…Adding to this complexity is also healthcare managers' strong taskorientation with a low tolerance for mistakes (Tortorella et al, 2020). These factors create a highly uncertain operational environment for healthcare providers, which has been amplified during the Covid-19 pandemic, where healthcare systems around the world have had to adapt quickly by re-allocating care capacity to face the large numbers of patients battling Covid-19 (Rennert-May et al, 2021;Stengel et al, 2022). This reality has strengthened the call from scholars for research to investigate OM phenomena related to healthcare (Micheli et al, 2021).…”