Reliability of Police-Reported Information for Determining Crash and Injury Severity

Abstract

Posted speed limit and police-reported injury codes are commonly used by researchers to approximate vehicle impact and occupant injury severity. In-depth crash investigations, however, produce more precise measures of crash and injury severity: change in velocity (delta-V) for crash severity and Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS) scores for injury severity. A comparison of data from police crash reports with that gathered by National Automotive Sampling System (NASS) investigators highlighted the inadequacy of speed limit and police injury codes as proxies for delta-V and AIS injury severity. In general, delta-V increased with speed limit and higher values of AIS were associated with higher police-coded injury severity, but there were a number of anomalies. In particular, 49% of the drivers coded by police as having incapacitating injuries actually had sustained no more than minor injuries. This overstatement of injury severity was less frequent among male (44%) and elderly (37%) drivers than among female (53%) and nonelderly (50%) drivers. Also, 79% of the investigated vehicles that crashed on roads posted at 60 mph (96 km/h) or higher experienced a delta-V less than 25 mph (40 km/h). Safety studies depending on data from only police reports to establish injury or crash severity therefore could produce erroneous results.

Motorcyclists’ Mortality Pattern in Colombia from 2000 to 2013: A Longitudinal Study

“…[85][86][87][88][89][90][91]. On the other hand, the records were, also, not correlated, with basic information such as policies to ease purchase of vehicles, price of gas, motorcyclist's perceptions and preferences for using a type of vehicle, among others [92][93][94][95].…”

Driver Fatigue and Road Safety on Poland’s National Roads

“…Young drivers (aged [18][19][20][21][22] are part of the high-risk group because of their lack of experience or knowledge how to handle fatigue, failure to understand potential threats or overestimating their ability to drive. There is a strong link between the frequency of night-time driving and the perception of risk of a fatigue-related accident.…”

“…This is so because of the injury and road accident definitions used by Polish police. The KABCO injury rating scale (widely used in the USA and in other countries) is a 5-point scale which consists of categories designated fatal (K), serious (A), moderate (B), minor (C), and none (O) [21].…”

“…When compared, the classification of personal injury in Poland and on the KABCO injury rating scale [21] shows that in fact Poland does not use one of the injury groups, i.e., minor injury (C on the KABCO scale). The level of injury considered as slight in Poland falls under moderate (category B) on the KABCO scale.…”

Modeling the Injury Prevention Impact of Mandatory Alcohol Ignition Interlock Installation in All New US Vehicles

“…3 The application of this correction to NASS-GES injury data was likely less accurate for moderate and minor injuries (B/C codes). The use of KABCO also has been previously shown to have limitations, 44 especially for differentiating among nonfatal injury types. These results should be interpreted cautiously, but KABCO remains the best available injury scale for a nationwide analysis of AI-MVC injuries.…”