Quarantine and testing strategies to reduce transmission risk from imported SARS-CoV-2 infections: a global modelling study

Abstract

Background Many countries require incoming air travellers to quarantine on arrival and/or undergo testing to limit importation of SARS-CoV-2. Methods We developed mathematical models of SARS-CoV-2 viral load trajectories over the course of infection to assess the effectiveness of quarantine and testing strategies. We consider the use of Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) and lateral flow testing (LFT) both pre-flight, to reduce the number of infectious arrivals and when exiting quarantine, and daily testing of arrivals with LFTs. We also estimate the effect of each strategy relative to domestic incidence, and limits of achievable risk reduction, for 99 countries where flight data and case numbers are estimated. Results We find that immediately pre-flight LFTs are more effective than PCR tests 3 days before departure in decreasing the number of departing infectious travellers. Pre-flight LFTs and post-flight quarantines, with tests to release, may prevent the majority of transmission from infectious arrivals while reducing the required duration of quarantine; a pre-flight LFT followed by 5 days in quarantine with a test to release would reduce the expected number of secondary cases generated by an infected traveller compared to symptomatic self-isolation alone, Rs, by 85% (95% UI: 74%, 96%) for PCR and 85% (95% UI: 70%, 96%) for LFT, even assuming imperfect adherence to quarantine (28% of individuals) and self-isolation following a positive test (86%). Under the same adherence assumptions, 5 days of daily LFT testing would reduce Rs by 91% (95% UI: 75%, 98%). Conclusions Strategies aimed at reducing the risk of imported cases should be considered with respect to: domestic incidence, transmission, and susceptibility; measures in place to support quarantining travellers; and incidence of new variants of concern in travellers' origin countries. Daily testing with LFTs for 5 days is comparable to 5 days of quarantine with a test on exit or 14 days with no test.

Diagnostics for COVID-19: moving from pandemic response to control

“…Many countries require travellers to present proof of a negative antigenic or molecular test result 72 h ahead of a flight, to quarantine after arrival, and to test negative with either a molecular test or Ag-RDT for release. 92 Although models of strategies to mitigate the importation risk have been published, 93 , 94 , 95 there is no global or regional consensus on any one risk-reduction strategy.…”

Effect of vaccination, border testing, and quarantine requirements on the risk of COVID-19 in New Zealand: A modelling study

“…This formulation assumes that all isolated individuals transmit at a reduced rate However, we expect average model outputs to be very similar if we instead assumed that a fraction of isolated individuals transmit at the same rate as a non-isolated individual and a fraction do not transmit at all ( Quilty et al, 2021 ). Individuals that develop symptoms after arrival seek a test with probability 80%.…”

“…The modelling approach is similar to that of ( Quilty et al, 2021 ), which estimated the reduction in transmission potential from a range of traveller interventions. The model of ( Quilty et al, 2021 ) modelled individual heterogeneity in viral load trajectories and assumed that the transmission rate and the probability of testing positive are both functions of the viral load. This requires that there is a unique one-to-one mapping between the transmission rate at time and the probability of testing positive at time .…”

Prevention SARS-CoV-2 importation at different stages of the COVID-19 epidemic in Serbia and the world, a review of practices and effects

“…Their findings suggested that there were effective alternative strategies with shorter quarantine and testing to prevent COVID-19 surges due to the importation of infected people as an effective replacement of the travel ban. [37]. The authors concluded that preflight antigen testing, with a five-day quarantine after entry into the country and an additional antigen test to exit quarantine, might prevent most COVID-19 transmissions, while reducing the duration of quarantine.…”