Promoting and Risk Factors of Nurses’ Hardiness Levels during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Results from an Italian Cohort

Abstract

Aim: Few studies in the literature specifically address the hardiness of nurses during the COVID-19 pandemic. Thus, the primary aim of this study was to assess the impact of COVID-19 on the hardiness levels in an Italian cohort of nurses. The secondary aims were to assess the level of hardiness in nurses directly caring for patients with COVID-19 and to verify the presence of related risk and promoting factors. Methods: A descriptive and explorative study was performed through an online survey from March to July 2020. The survey was composed of a multiple answer questionnaire with open, closed, and semi-closed-ended questions. Hardiness and anxiety were assessed using two psychometric instruments: the Dispositional Resilience Scale (DRS-15) and State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI-Y). Results: A total of 1250 nurses completed the questionnaire entirely (92.3% of respondents). The average length of service was 17.8 ± 11.5 years. A decrease in the hardiness was recorded after the first wave of COVID-19 if compared to the baseline (mean Δ DRS-15 total = 1.3 ± 5.0), whereas in the subsample of nurses caring for COVID-19 patients, the total hardiness level decreased more consistently (mean Δ DRS Total = 1.9 + 5.3). Multivariate analysis showed that high levels of anxiety were risk factors for reducing hardiness. In contrast, anxiety, when associated with a greater length of service, was a promoting factor for the increase in hardiness. Conclusions:The correlation between anxiety and years of length of service appears to be pivotal. Future research should focus on the role of anxiety to establish its actual role as a predictor of hardiness.

Nurses’ personal perceptions of clinical work adaptation during COVID-19

“…Resilience in front line healthcare workers has been examined by other investigators. 20 , 21 Authors found that resilience was important in coping and maintaining mental health. In evidence gathered prior to the pandemic, authors indicated that resilience was an adaptive factor for nurses during difficult situations, even transforming challenges into positive experiences and professional growth.…”

Evaluation of Medical Staff Satisfaction for Workplace Architecture in Temporary COVID-19 Hospital: A Case Study in Gdańsk, Poland

“…During the three years of the pandemic, many studies were prepared to describe the experience of medical personnel in the fight against COVID-19 in various countries and various medical units [19,21]. The results of this ongoing research have shown that working during the pandemic has had a very large impact on the personal and professional lives of nurses, as they are one of the most exposed professional groups due to direct contact with patients.…”

A study on optimism as a psychological strength in nurses through a prospective study from the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic to two years later

“…In the context of the pandemic, despite the scarce existing studies, hardiness has shown a protective role in nurses. Of particular relevance is that anxiety, when associated with a greater length of service, has been found to be a promoting factor for hardiness, showing that anxiety is not always associated with a decrease in hardiness ( Baldassini Rodriguez et al 2022 ). It has been pointed out that the presence, activation and effects of hardiness are not universal, making it of great interest to analyze the variables and processes that influence the mobilization of strengths in the implementation of advanced nursing ( Druart and Blanchard, 2022 ).…”