Political culture and structures of social control: Police‐related scandal in the low countries in comparative perspective

Abstract

Comparative studies of police have been a staple of the criminological tradition in Britain at least since Michael Banton's pioneering work on the sociology of the police organisation in the early 1960s. This paper focuses on cases of police-related scandal in the Low Countries as a way of illustrating the importance of the political-cultural component in comparative policing. It begins with an historical overview of the polities of the Netherlands and Belgium and examines the structural evolution of the police system in those countries. An account of some police-related scandals is then given. Such scandals provide particularly good data for understanding the political and cultural embeddedness of policing, since such scandals are reflective not only of police practices, but are also constituted within culturally relevant terms of political discourse which help shape the machinery of governance, including police. The lessons that can be drawn from this case study are twofold. On the one hand, this paper will show that comparative criminologists need to be extremely cautious in making general statements based on abstracted models of police systems and organisational frameworks, since such general models are inattentive to the cultural embeddedness of the crime control enterprise. The cultural meaning of police and policing, it is argued, ought to receive more attention in the comparative police literature. On the other hand, those concerned to analyse policy

International Policing in Russia: Police Co-operation Between the European Union Member States and the Russian Federation

“…It reflects the history of the Nordic countries (Finland, Sweden, Norway, Denmark and Iceland), and the fact that these countries are closely related, not only geographically, but also culturally and socially. This situation is an exception in the EU, since not only do the law enforcement systems vary widely (Anderson, 2002), but their foundations, i.e., national cultures, do so as well (Hofstede, 1991;Sheptycki, 1999). It is, therefore, by no means evident that such close co-operation will easily emerge between any of the other EU Member States, if at all.…”

’The trapeze artists and the ground crew’police cooperation and intelligence exchange mechanisms in Europe and North America: A comparative empirical study

“…This affair can be seen as one the most recent revelations in a cascade of similar affairs, where one police is inquiring on another police's methods, while they each compete on their own side to close cases with formal accusations (Sheptycki, 1999b). They are pressured in such a way by politicians and public opinion when the process seems too slow, and such pressure results in the transfer of a case from one police service to another (Van 16 M. ALAIN Outrive, Cartuyvels and Ponsaers, 1991).…”

Policing in a Changing Vietnam

“…The extent to which broader social and cultural environments shape police occupational cultures has been the subject of comparative studies with a range of foci (for example, Banton, 1964;Bayley, 1976Bayley, , 1990Cassan, 2010;Choi & Lee, 2016;Chu, 2017;Jiao, 2001;Sheptycki, 1999;Sun & Chu, 2006). The nature of policing often takes on various forms depending on the history and development of institutions and the broader social context.…”