“…Of course, the use of a retrieval technique (e.g., neural network or 1-D-variational) using prior physical information should further improve the estimation: for instance, the surface layer should clearly benefit from prior knowledge of the surface temperature and total water vapor content. In fact, a comparison with existing works based on methods combining physical constraints with statistical tools (Kuo et al, 1994;Cabrera-Mercadier and Staelin, 1995;Rieder and Kirchengast, 1999;Liu and Weng, 2005;Aires et al, 2013) applied to on similar radiometers with less channels in the 183.31 GHz line, such as AMSU-B or MHS, shows that the current approach gives similar performance (root mean square errors of about 10 %RH in the mid-troposphere). It is also consistent with the layer-averaged RH profiles estimated by the Indian team involved in the Megha-Tropiques mission, although further constraining the retrieval by NCEP/NCAR outputs (Venkat Ratnam et al, 2013;Gohil et al, 2013).…”