Patient engagement as a risk factor in personalized health care: a systematic review of the literature on chronic disease

Abstract

BackgroundThe role of patient engagement as an important risk factor for healthcare outcomes has not been well established. The objective of this article was to systematically review the relationship between patient engagement and health outcomes in chronic disease to determine whether patient engagement should be quantified as an important risk factor in health risk appraisals to enhance the practice of personalized medicine.MethodsA systematic review of prospective clinical trials conducted between January 1993 and December 2012 was performed. Articles were identified through a medical librarian-conducted multi-term search of Medline, Embase, and Cochrane databases. Additional studies were obtained from the references of meta-analyses and systematic reviews on hypertension, diabetes, and chronic care. Search terms included variations of the following: self-care, self-management, self-monitoring, (shared) decision-making, patient education, patient motivation, patient engagement, chronic disease, chronically ill, and randomized controlled trial. Studies were included only if they: (1) compared patient engagement interventions to an appropriate control among adults with chronic disease aged 18 years and older; (2) had minimum 3 months between pre- and post-intervention measurements; and (3) defined patient engagement as: (a) understanding the importance of taking an active role in one’s health and health care; (b) having the knowledge, skills, and confidence to manage health; and (c) using knowledge, skills and confidence to perform health-promoting behaviors. Three authors and two research assistants independently extracted data using predefined fields including quality metrics.ResultsWe reviewed 543 abstracts to identify 10 trials that met full inclusion criteria, four of which had ‘high’ methodological quality (Jadad score ≥ 3). Diverse measurement of patient engagement prevented robust statistical analyses, so data were qualitatively described. Nine studies documented improvements in patient engagement. Five studies reported reduction in clinical markers of disease (for example HbA1C). All studies reported improvements in self-reported health status.ConclusionsThis review suggests patient engagement should be quantified as part of a comprehensive health risk appraisal given its apparent value in helping individuals to effectively self-manage chronic disease. Patient engagement measures should include assessment of the knowledge, confidence and skills to prevent and manage chronic disease, plus the behaviors to do so.

Patient Engagement as Measured by Inpatient Portal Use: Methodology for Log File Analysis (Preprint)

“…Information and technology alone, however, are insufficient to fully engage patients in their care − patients also need motivation to engage [31][32][33][34][35]. A common element of health behavior change theories is the need for a trigger to action [29,36].…”

Psychometric properties of Multidimensional Health Locus of Control - A and General Self-Efficacy Scale in civil servants: ELSA-Brasil Musculoskeletal Study (ELSA-Brasil MSK)

“…When it comes to the patients’ perspective, engagement can be understood under a tripartite definition, which includes their recognition of the importance to play an active role in their own health and health care, their self-management capability, and health-promoting behaviors 4 . Increasing attention has been given to the development of strategies that empower individuals to engage in the prevention and management of long-term illnesses 5 , 6 .…”

The quantified patient: a patient participatory culture

“…Quantified patient applications facilitate patients' abilities to monitor themselves and for clinicians to use this information to improve quality of care, decreasing patient readmission rates, promoting positive and long-lasting behavioral and lifestyle changes, monitoring and better controlling chronic diseases, increasing information for preventive care, and promoting overall wellbeing 9,10 . In chronic diseases such as hypertension or diabetes, patients are provided a forum for documenting and reporting daily readings, logging intake, and setting reminders and alarms for medication adherence.…”