Participatory design of a preliminary safety checklist for general practice

Abstract

BackgroundThe use of checklists to minimise errors is well established in high reliability, safety-critical industries. In health care there is growing interest in checklists to standardise checking processes and ensure task completion, and so provide further systemic defences against error and patient harm. However, in UK general practice there is limited experience of safety checklist use. AimTo identify workplace hazards that impact on safety, health and wellbeing, and performance, and codesign a standardised checklist process. Design and settingApplication of mixed methods to identify system hazards in Scottish general practices and develop a safety checklist based on human factors design principles. MethodA multiprofessional 'expert' group (n = 7) and experienced front-line GPs, nurses, and practice managers (n = 18) identified system hazards and developed and validated a preliminary checklist using a combination of literature review, documentation review, consensus building workshops using a mini-Delphi process, and completion of content validity index exercise. ResultsA prototype safety checklist was developed and validated consisting of six safety domains (for example, medicines management), 22 sub-categories (for example, emergency drug supplies) and 78 related items (for example, stock balancing, secure drug storage, and cold chain temperature recording). ConclusionHazards in the general practice work system were prioritised that can potentially impact on the safety, health and wellbeing of patients, GP team members, and practice performance, and a necessary safety checklist prototype was designed. However, checklist efficacy in improving safety processes and outcomes is dependent on user commitment, and support from leaders and promotional champions. Although further usability development and testing is necessary, the concept should be of interest in the UK and internationally.

Test check pilot list of safe surgery: experience report / Teste piloto de checklist de cirurgia segura: relato de experiência / Lista de chequeo de cirugía segura: relato de experiencia

“…Ela exige uma transição de uma cultura de silêncio, e de punição para uma cultura de mudança, visando um sistema mais seguro. No entanto, para uma cultura de segurança é primordial uma política de educação permanente (11)(12) . Essa proposta fez parte da história do hospital nessa construção de uma política de segurança do paciente despertando sobre a necessidade de incorporação de processos que reduzam desconformidades na rotina da unidade.…”

A segurança do paciente nos caminhos percorridos pela enfermagem brasileira

“…In this scenario, ensuring safe healthcare is directly related to a multifaceted context involving several care processes, of different degrees of complexity and requiring different resources. Then, it is clear that many problems identified in the healthcare provision process, such as limited or scarce resources, work overload due to insufficient number of professionals and poor qualification of professionals, have a negative influence on PS (21)(22)(23) . It is undeniable nurses are increasingly seeking professional progress, dedicating efforts to achieve better qualification and provide high-quality and safe healthcare services, based on scientific evidence.…”

Human factors in general practice – early thoughts on the educational focus for specialty training and beyond

“…Incident investigations and risk assessments focus to identify 'causes', consequences and the likelihood of unsafe outcomes and then eliminate or install barriers to minimise occurrence or impacts. An important part of risk assessment is to understand the hazards present within the GP surgery and the risk that these hazards present to patients or staff in the context of the way people normally work there [30]. Individual responsibility, a willingness to highlight incidents and a reporting system that recognises the whole sociotechnical system and associated hazards is necessary to create a proactive approach to safety management.…”