Observations on recent mass mortality events of marine mussels in the Oosterschelde, the Netherlands

Abstract

Two mass mortality events (MMEs) of marine mussels that took place in the Oosterschelde, the Netherlands—the first in 2015/2016 and the second in 2019—both severely affected mussel production. The current study presents our observations on the onset and course of both MMEs and discusses probable putative causes. The two MMEs displayed a distinct course of events. The first event started in November 2015 with high mortality rates on culture plots, which remained elevated until the autumn of 2016. Approximately 40–50% of mussels from all age classes were lost on culture plots and 100% were lost from wild seed beds. The second event started in April–May 2019 and continued until the end of July, with mortality ranging from 20 to 100%, again from all age classes. Culture areas other than the Oosterschelde and other shellfish species were not affected. Histological and bacteriological screening produced no evidence for common pathogens or pollution as a primary mortality factor and there is no indication of abnormal environmental conditions preceding or during the events. We hypothesize that a cumulation of stressors results in weakening of the mussels and in elevated mortality rates. In 2019, this cumulation of stressors could be high spawning activities (an unusual high concentration of mussel larvae was found in April) that resulted in very low condition from April to June, a Phaeocystis bloom in April to May that prevented a quick recovery, and the development of granulocytomas that were found in up to 60 to 70% of live mussels as a consequence of cumulative stress. Although no (single) putative causes could be identified, this study contributes to the knowledge on MMEs in mussels and fits in a wider and disturbing trend on mortality events in shellfish.

Declining Populations of Mytilus spp. in North Atlantic Coastal Waters—A Swedish Perspective

“…For example, unusually high spawning activities followed by a Phaeocystis mass occurrence caused two mass mortality events in the Dutch Oosterschelde in 2016 and 2019. This was associated with high prevalence of granulocytomas indicating cumultative stress in the mussels (Capelle et al 2021). Climate change results in higher water temperature, and OA as well as extreme weather events exacerbate the prevailing stressors as described earlier (Petoukhov et al 2016, Bindoff et al 2019, Collins et al 2019.…”

Out of their depth: The successful use of cultured subtidal mussels for intertidal restoration

“…Nevertheless, at temperatures over 40 C even intertidally reared mussels experience increased hormonal perturbations, loss of neural control, and failure of protein synthesis (Dunphy et al, 2015(Dunphy et al, , 2018Zamora et al, 2019). These effects culminate in mass mortality events for wild intertidal mussels when extreme heat waves correspond with low tides (Capelle et al, 2021;Seuront et al, 2019;Tsuchiya, 1983). This problem is exacerbated in a warming global climate that increases the likelihood of extreme heat waves that will directly affect the internal body temperatures of bivalves (Gilman et al, 2006;IPCC, 2022).…”

Identifying how restoration measures influence the presence of shorebirds: a case study on the use of artificial structures for restoring mussel reefs

“…The month of March is missing from the dataset as during this month, the plots did not emerge four times due to stormy weather. The counting of birds was stopped after April because of a mass mortality event throughout the Oosterschelde (Capelle et al 2021).…”