Several methods for isolation of the paracrystalline surface (S) layer protein (RsaA) of Caulobacter crescentus CB15A were evaluated. Treatment of cells with HEPES (N-2-hydroxyethylpiperazine-N'-2-ethanesulfonic acid) buffer at pH 2 was the most effective means of selectively removing RsaA from cells, and after neutralization, the protein was capable of reassembling into a paracrystalline structure. Ethylene glycol-bis(13-aminoethyl ether)-N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid treatment could also be used to extract RsaA and yielded protein capable of reassembly. The success of the methods was likely related to disruption of calcium-mediated bonding; calcium was required for recrystallization, while magnesium and strontium ions were ineffective. Antibody was raised against purified RsaA and, along with the S-layer extraction techniques, was used to evaluate 42 strains of caulobacters isolated from a variety of aquatic and wastewater treatment locations. A single characteristic protein could be isolated from the 35 strains that produced an S layer; with one exception, no proteins were extracted from strains that had no S layer. The presumed S-layer proteins ranged in size from 100 to 193 kDa.All of these proteins specifically reacted with anti-RsaA serum by Western immunoblot analysis. In strain CB15A, a specific S-layer-associated oligosaccharide has been proposed to be involved in a calcium-mediated attachment of the S layer to the cell surface. This molecule was detected by Western immunoblotting with a specific antiserum and on polyacrylamide gels stained for polysaccharides. A comparable band was found in all S-layer-producing strains and for most, S-layer-associated oligosaccharide-specific antibody reacted with them in Western analysis. Overall, in freshwater caulobacters at least portions of their S-layer structures appear to be strongly conserved entities, as well as the means of attachment to the cell surface.Caulobacters are one of many genera of bacteria that elaborate a paracrystalline surface (S) layer on their outermost surface (37). The S layer of one species, Caulobacter crescentus, has received the most attention, but in a survey of caulobacters isolated from wastewater treatment systems the most common type of caulobacter we encountered shares morphological similarities with C. crescentus strains, including a hexagonally packed S-layer structure (27).The cloned S-layer protein gene of C. crescentus CB15hybridized to specific regions of the genome for most of these S-layer-producing caulobacters, yet only under moderate-stringency conditions, and restriction length polymorphism analysis with the S-layer gene as the probe failed to reveal patterns of close relatedness between the strains (27).This was recently correlated with a 16S rRNA comparative analysis which showed that these caulobacters were a coherent group but still sufficiently different to have significant variation in their overall genomic DNA composition (41). We were interested in determining how similar their S-layer structures are from the s...