Crystal structures of nickel-dependent superoxide dismutases (NiSODs) reveal the presence of a H-bonding network formed between the N-H of the apical imidazole ligand from His1 and the Glu17 carboxylate from a neighboring subunit in the hexameric enzyme. This interaction is supported by another intra-subunit H-bond between Glu17 and Arg47. In this study, four mutant NiSOD proteins were produced to experimentally evaluate the roles of this H-bonding network, and compare the results with prior predictions from DFT calculations. H1A-NiSOD, which lacks the apical ligand entirely, was crystallographically characterized and reveals that in the absence of the Glu17-His1 H-bond, the active site is disordered. Subsequent characterization using X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) shows that Ni(II) is bound in the expected N2S2 planar coordination site. Despite these structural perturbations, the H1A-NiSOD variant is an active catalyst with 4% of WT-NiSOD activity. Three other mutations were designed to preserve the apical imidazole ligand, but perturb the H-bonding network: R47A-NiSOD, lacks the intra-molecular H-bonding interaction, E17R/R47A-NiSOD, which retains the intra-molecular H-bond, but lacks the inter-molecular Glu17-His1 H-bond, and E17A/R47A-NiSOD, which lacks both H-bonding interactions. These variants were characterized by a combination of techniques including XAS characterization of the nickel site structure, kinetic studies employing pulse-radiolytic production of superoxide, and EPR and chemical probes of the redox activity. The results indicate that in addition to the roles in redox tuning suggested by the computational models, the Glu17-His1 H-bond plays an important structural role in the formation of the Ni-hook motif that is a critical feature of the active site.