My self as an other: on autoimmunity and “other” paradoxes

Abstract

The rubric autoimmunity currently encompasses sixty to seventy diverse illnesses which affect many of the tissues of the human body. Western medical practice asserts that the crisis known as autoimmune disease arises when a biological organism compromises its own integrity by misrecognising parts of itself as other than itself and then seeks to eliminate these unrecognised and hence antagonistic aspects of itself. That is, autoimmune illnesses seem to manifest the contradictory and sometimes deadly proposition that the “identity”: body/self both is and is not “itself”. Based on the assumption that under normal circumstances “the self” ought to coincide naturally with “the body”—or at the very least the self ought to inhabit the living location of the body more or less unproblematically—this scientific paradigm depicts autoimmune illness as a vital paradox. Yet for those of us who have lived through the experience of an autoimmune crisis, the living paradox that we embody may also lead us to question the basis upon which these medical assumptions rest. This essay raises some of these questions.

After the clinic? Researching sexual health technology in context

“…Ed Cohen (2004) traced out the genealogy of juridical and biological concepts in biomedicine, making the point that notions of one's ownership of one's body can be traced into the emergence of liberal philosophy in the late-seventeenth century. Cohen argues that this idea of one's body as one's own supports the individualism of latemodern democracies and permeates modern biomedicine.…”

“Euro-Islam”: Going Beyond the Aporiatic Politics of Othering1

“…Auto‐immunity, termed by Derrida as “illogical logic,” stands for the biological process through which an organism turns against its own self‐protection (Cohen 2004). The immune system, which is supposed to protect the body from outside threats, turns against the healthy cells of the body “sensing” them as threats and thus attacks them (Derrida 2003:41–42).…”

The disease-subject as a subject of literature

“…Could we learn to live otherwise?" These are questions asked by a perceptive patient whose autoimmune disease threatens his body as well as his subjective integrity [15]. Or consider subjectivity when directly attacked by such a disease as depression, which both gnaws at the fabric of the lived body and issues paralyzing orders to the living body.…”