Mental Health Conceptualization and Resilience Factors in the Kalasha Youth: An Indigenous Ethnic and Religious Minority Community in Pakistan

Abstract

The Kalasha are a religious, ethnic, and linguistic minority community in Pakistan. They are indigenous people living in remote valleys of the Hindu Kush Mountains in northern Pakistan, neighboring Afghanistan. The Kalasha are pastoral, as well as agricultural people to some extent, although they are increasingly facing pressures from globalization and social change, which may be influencing youth and community development. Their traditional world view dichotomizes and emphasizes on the division of the pure (Onjeshta) and the impure (Pragata). There remains a scarcity of literature on mental health and resilience of indigenous communities in South Asia and Pakistan generally, and the polytheistic Kalasha community specifically. Thus, the current study was conducted with the aim to explore the cultural protective factors (resilience) of the Kalasha youth (adolescents and emerging adults) and to explore their perceived etiological understandings and preferred interventions for mental health support systems. The theoretical framework of Bronfenbrenner's (1, 2) ecological systems model was used. Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) was conducted, considering the advantage of its idiographic approach and the “double hermeneutic” analytic process. This methodology was consistent with the aim to understand and make sense of mental health and resilience from the Kalasha indigenous perspective. A total of 12 in-depth interviews were conducted with adolescents and emerging adults (5 males, 7 females), along with ethnographic observations. The analysis revealed 3 superordinate themes of mental health perceptions and interventions, each with more specific emergent themes: (1) Psychological Resilience/Cultural Protective Factors Buffering Against Mental Health Problems (Intra-Communal Bonding & Sharing; Kalasha Festivals & Traditions; Purity Concept; Behavioral Practice of Happiness and Cognitive Patterns); (2) Perceived Causes of Mental Health Issues (Biological & Psychosocial; Supernatural & Spiritual; Environmental); and (3) Preferred Interventions [Shamanic Treatment; Ta'awiz (Amulets); Communal Sharing & Problem Solving; Medical Treatment; Herbal Methods]. The overall findings point to the need for developing culturally-sensitive and indigenous measures and therapeutic interventions. The findings highlighted the Kalasha cultural practices which may promote resilience. The findings also call for indigenous sources of knowledge to be considered when collaboratively designing public health programs.

Mental health literacy in Pakistan: a narrative review

“…Likewise, low mental literacy is the cause of abuse in mental health care facilities which results in restraining or chaining patients with mental disorders (Michael et al, 2012). Since the last few years, mental health has remained a subject of debate in Pakistan (Naz and Khalily, 2016;Choudhry and Bokharey, 2013;Choudhry et al, 2017Choudhry et al, , 2018. In the background of growing terrorism, insecurity, constant poverty, stress, unemployment and disruption of the social fabric, the incidence and prevalence of mental health issues have increased tremendously (Gadit and Vahidy, 1999;Choudhry et al, 2016).…”

“…However, in Pakistan, the budget fixed for mental health is less than 2 percent (Afridi, 2008;Rathod et al, 2017). Due to a limited number of psychiatrists and psychologists (one psychiatrist is hired for more than 10,000 people), poor conditions/facilities of Basic Health Units (BHU), the majority of patients visit traditional faith healers (Choudhry and Bokharey, 2013;Choudhry et al, 2017Choudhry et al, , 2018Choudhry, Munawar, Akram, Al-Worafi, Bakrin, Tey, Jacob, Hing, Khan, Han and Kamal, 2019;Akbari et al, 2009). According to an estimate, there are a total of 203.07 (per 100,000 populations) professionals offering services in various mental health institutes either privately or under government practice.…”

Generosity Linked to Spirituality, Resilience and Psychological Well-Being Among Youth: The Psychology of Goodness

“…In the evolutionary biological study of cooperation, it is widely accepted that humans cooperate in a wide variety of ways and on large scales (Townsend, Aktipis, Balliet & Cronk, 2020). The empirical shred of evidence also found that generosity, life-management skills, and social selfefficacy beliefs play an important in promoting ones' goodness towards life in general especially when it comes to their interest and belief in activities for the common good (Van Dyke, et, al., 2009); Koenig, 2012; Choudhry, et al, 2018). As the youth gets more and more involved in interpersonal generosity it fosters their resiliency to combat stressors of life due to the remarkable benefits they earned for attaining spiritual wealth and mental health.…”

Public Perception About the Zika Virus in Working Professionals: A Qualitative Inquiry

“…The interview-based methods are famous in health-care studies and semistructured interviews are usually based on a flexible topic guide that offers a loose structure of open-ended questions to explore experiences and attitudes. 19–24 Especially when some urgent assessment is required for a public health problem, the studies based on social media trending are beneficial for policymakers and help to plan some immediate interventions. This analysis covers a broad range of analytic approaches (e.g., intuitive, impressionistic, interpretive analyses, as well as strict textual and systematic analyses).…”