Telomeres are bound by dedicated protein complexes, like shelterin in mammals, which protect telomeres from DNA damage. In the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, a comprehensive understanding of the proteins interacting with the telomere sequence is lacking. Here, we harnessed a quantitative proteomics approach to screen for proteins binding to C. elegans telomeres, and identified TEBP-1 and TEBP-2, two paralogs that associate to telomeres in vitro and in vivo. TEBP-1 and TEBP-2 are expressed in the germline and during embryogenesis. tebp-1 and tebp-2 mutants display strikingly distinct phenotypes: tebp-1 mutants have longer telomeres than wild-type animals, while tebp-2 mutants display shorter telomeres and a mortal germline, a phenotype characterized by transgenerational germline deterioration. Notably, tebp-1; tebp-2 double mutant animals have synthetic sterility, with germlines showing signs of severe mitotic and meiotic arrest. TEBP-1 and TEBP-2 form a telomeric complex with the known single-stranded telomere-binding proteins POT-1, POT-2, and MRT-1. Furthermore, we find that POT-1 bridges the double stranded binders TEBP-1 and TEBP-2, with the single-stranded binders POT-2 and MRT-1. These results describe the first telomere-binding complex in C. elegans, with TEBP-1 and TEBP-2, two double-stranded telomere binders required for fertility and that mediate opposite telomere dynamics.