Match Running Performance in Young Soccer Players: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Background To date, athletic performance has been extensively assessed in youth soccer players through laboratory and field testing. Only recently has running performance via time-motion analysis been assessed during match play. Match running data are often useful in a practical context to aid game understanding and decision making regarding training content and prescriptions. A plethora of previous reviews have collated and appraised the literature on time-motion analysis in professional senior players, but none have solely examined youth players. Objective The aim of the present systematic review was to provide a critical appraisal and summary of the original research articles that have evaluated match running performance in young male soccer players. Methods Following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses (PRISMA) statement, literature searches were performed in four databases: PubMed, ISI Web of Science, SPORTDiscus and SciELO. We used the following descriptors: soccer, football, young, youth, junior, physical performance, running performance, match running performance, movement patterns, time-motion analysis, distances covered, activity profile, work rate, match analysis, and match performance. Articles were included only if they were original articles written in the English language, studied populations of male children and/or adolescents (aged ≤ 20 years), were published/ahead of print on or before 31 December 2017 and showed at least one outcome measure regarding match running performance, such as total distance covered, peak game speed or indicators of activities performed at established speed thresholds. Results A total of 5801 records were found. After duplicates were removed and exclusion and inclusion criteria applied, 50 articles were included (n = 2615 participants). Their outcome measures were extracted and findings were synthesized. The majority of the reviewed papers covered the European continent (62%) and used global positioning systems (GPS) (64%). Measurement error of the tools used to obtain position data and running metrics was systematically overlooked among the studies. The main aims of studies were to examine differences across playing positions (20%), age groups (26%) and match halves (36%). Consistent findings pointed to the existence of positional role and age effects on match running output (using fixed running speed thresholds), but there was no clear consensus about reductions in activity over the course of match play. Congested schedules negatively affected players' running performance. While over 32% of all studies assessed the relationships between match running performance and physical capacity, biochemical markers and body composition, ~ 70% of these did not account for playing position. Conclusions This review collated scientific evidence that can aid soccer conditioning professionals in understanding external match loads across youth categories. Coaches working with youth development programs should consider that data derived from a given po...

Reliability and validity of field‐based fitness tests in youth soccer players

“…Hence, extremely limited data exist regarding the importance and prevalence of strength and power characteristics during youth soccer match-play. As discussed earlier (Section 2.2.1.2), strength and power characteristics are widely accepted to contribute during performance of explosive actions such as jumps, changes in direction, accelerations and decelerations, all of which are prevalent during youth soccer match performance (Buchheit et al, 2010;Mendez-Villanueva et al, 2013;Palucci Vieira et al, 2019). Consequently, developing strength and power ability may improve effectiveness during these actions, thus improving soccer performance.…”

“…In contrast, Carling et al (2009) report few differences between relatively older and younger U14 players. Though these conflicting studies suggest relationships between maturity and match-running performance remain unclear, consideration of the entire bed of literature suggests that maturity status should be considered when evaluating runningdemands in youth soccer (Palucci Vieira et al, 2019).…”

“… Consideration must be made to discrepancies between youth and senior soccer when considering physical characteristics, both in terms of match demands (Palucci Vieira et al, 2019) and physical characteristics/capacities (Grossmann & Lames, 2015) of these samples.…”

A Systematic Review of Children’s Physical Activity Patterns: Concept, Operational Definitions, Instruments, Statistical Analyses, and Health Implications

“…Then, the articles selected were analysed for their data quality, taking into account seven quality criteria developed ad hoc that were adapted for previous studies [ 25 , 26 ] ( Table 1 ), which were scored on a three-point scale, and the sum of these points (from 0 to 14 points), meaning the methodological quality rating (which was represented in a percentage scale). This procedure was performed by two independent reviewers, separately, and if discrepancies arose, they were solved by common agreement.…”

Contrary to endurance, power associated capacities differ between different aged and starting-nonstarting elite junior soccer players

“…During the last decade, the high-intensity running distances increased up to~35% in the English Premier League [4]. Due to this development, that can also be expected to have been occurred across all age groups [5], it is presently important to evaluate anthropometric characteristics and physical capacities of soccer players by specific testing procedures on a regular basis. Since it is well known that junior players perform more high-intensity actions during play than older players [6], a regular testing is especially important for juniors.…”