Managing stigma in adolescent HIV: silence, secrets and sanctioned spaces

Abstract

HIV is conceived as a disease that combines stigma elements of perceived contagion and socially undesirable behaviours. Drawing on in-depth interviews with professional adolescent service providers from Australia, Canada, the UK and the USA, this paper explores HIV stigma and stigma management in the lives of HIV-positive young people. Findings elucidate how additional layers of stigma relating to 'adolescent rights' and 'embodied innocence' are added to HIV stigma as it is more usually conceived. This study suggests that managing this stigma entails managing silence in the context of the social worlds of the young person, the family and the service provider. Silence emerged as a key theme in the participant narratives and was embedded in the descriptions of young people's lived experiences. Crucially, silence is a product of oppression and inequity but is also a tool for resistance. Silence defends secrets and exists in the spaces, both physical and social, that are created for them in order to manage the stigma in young people's lives. Silences associated with HIV therefore need to be exposed if we are to better understand what HIV truly means to seropositive young people and how 'silences' may minimise or exacerbate their experience of HIV stigma inside and outside the context of programmes.

“Don't Tell Him You Have HIV Unless He's ‘The One’”: Romantic Relationships Among Adolescents and Young Adults with Perinatal HIV Infection

“…40 Medical providers in one study noted that AYA with PHIV ''manage stigma'' by taking extensive precautions when initiating and engaging in romantic relationships in order to minimize the risk of rejection. 41 Similarly, fear of rejection was widespread among participants in the current study. However, most strongly encouraged others living with PHIV to seek relationships despite the stigma of HIV/AIDS.…”

Transitioning HIV-infected adolescents to adult care at 14 clinics across the United States: using adolescent and adult providers’ insights to create multi-level solutions to address transition barriers

“…While research has explored care linkage and engagement for newly diagnosed adolescents, little work has examined adolescents’ HCT-related barriers. At the structural level, newly diagnosed adolescents struggle with HIV-related stigma(Fielden, Chapman, & Cadell, 2011), poverty(Kempf et al, 2010), housing(Gardner et al, 2009), insurance eligibility(Lillie-Blanton et al, 2010) and limited transportation options, factors that likely impact adolescents’ HCT(Kempf et al, 2010). Research from initial linkage and other chronic diseases suggests that HCT obstacles at the clinic level could include a lack of inter-clinic communication,(Gilliam et al, 2011) adolescent providers’ unwillingness to relinquish care,(Valenzuela et al, 2011) and adult providers’ limited adolescent-specific training(Reiss, Gibson, & Walker, 2005).…”

Let's talk about sex: reflections on conversations about love and sexuality in Kumasi and Endwa, Ghana

“…4. A similar point has been made by Fielden, Chapman and Cadell (2011) for HIV-positive young people's silences. 5.…”