Making short-term climate forecasts useful: Linking science and action

Abstract

This paper discusses the evolution of scientific and social understanding that has led to the development of knowledge systems supporting the application of El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) forecasts, including the development of successful efforts to connect climate predictions with sectoral applications and actions "on the ground". The evolution of "boundary-spanning" activities to connect science and decisionmaking is then discussed, setting the stage for a report of outcomes from an international workshop comprised of producers, translators, and users of climate predictions. The workshop, which focused on identifying critical boundary-spanning features of successful boundary organizations, included participants from Australia, Hawaii, and the Pacific Islands, the US Pacific Northwest, and the state of Ceará in northwestern Brazil. Workshop participants agreed that boundary organizations have multiple roles including those of information broker, convenor of forums for engagement, translator of scientific information, arbiter of access to knowledge, and exemplar of adaptive behavior. Through these roles, boundary organizations will ensure the stability of the knowledge system in a changing political, economic, and climatic context. The international examples reviewed in this workshop demonstrated an interesting case of convergent evolution, where organizations that were very different in origin evolved toward similar structures and individuals engaged in them had similar experiences to share. These examples provide evidence that boundary organizations and boundary-spanners fill some social/institutional roles that are independent of culture.boundary organization | decision support | El Niño-Southern Oscillation | knowledge

Toward a General Theory of Boundary Work: Insights from the CGIAR's Natural Resource Management Programs

“…In cases of a single source of relevant expertise (S1U1), this applies to what has been called "client oriented advising" (Andrews 2002, 12) as well as to the long tradition of scientific advice to leaders in government (Golden 1991). The challenge remains essentially the same, if the solutions are more complicated, where there are multiple sources of knowledge but still single decision makers (SnU1), as in so-called "farming systems research" and other participatory forms of analysis in which decision makers take an active role (Andrews 2002, 12;Carr and Wilkinson 2005;Buizer et al 2010).…”

Agricultural Advisors: A Receptive Audience for Weather and Climate Information?

“…However, few studies have specifically explored the role of agricultural advisors in using weather/climate information to help farmers make decisions (but see Buizer et al 2010).…”

Navigating complexity through knowledge coproduction: Mainstreaming ecosystem services into disaster risk reduction

“…This focus on learning, often referred to as social learning, has been highlighted by several authors as a key element in building the adaptive capacity and resilience needed to deal with change and uncertainty (59,(68)(69)(70). Such learning has been shown to be particularly useful in bringing together different knowledge systems and approaches necessary for developing an understanding of the system and designing management responses (28,31,71).…”