Directional preference in catalysis is often used to distinguish alcohol dehydrogenases from carbonyl reductases. However, the mechanistic basis underpinning this discrimination is weak. In mannitol 2-dehydrogenase from Pseudomonas fluorescens, stabilization of (partial) negative charge on the substrate oxyanion by the side chains of Asn-191 and Asn-300 is a key feature of catalysis in the direction of alcohol oxidation. We have disrupted this ability through individual and combined substitutions of the two asparagines by aspartic acid. Kinetic data and their thermodynamic analysis show that the internal equilibrium of enzyme-NADH-fructose and enzyme-NAD ؉ -mannitol (K int ) was altered dramatically (10 4 -to 10 5 -fold) from being balanced in the wild-type enzyme (K int ≈ 3) to favoring enzyme-NAD ؉ -mannitol in the single site mutants, N191D and N300D.The change in K int reflects a selective slowing down of the mannitol oxidation rate, resulting because Asn 3 Asp replacement (i) disfavors partial abstraction of alcohol proton by Lys-295 in a step preceding catalytic hydride transfer, and (ii) causes stabilization of a nonproductive enzyme-NAD ؉ -mannitol complex.N191D and N300D appear to lose fructose binding affinity due to deprotonation of the respective Asp above apparent pK values of 5.3 ؎ 0.1 and 6.3 ؎ 0.2, respectively. The mutant incorporating both Asn3 Asp substitutions behaved as a slow "fructose reductase" at pH 5.2, lacking measurable activity for mannitol oxidation in the pH range 6.8 -10. A mechanism is suggested in which polarization of the substrate carbonyl by a doubly protonated diad of Asp and Lys-295 facilitates NADH-dependent reduction of fructose by N191D and N300D under optimum pH conditions. Creation of an effectively "one-way" reductase by active-site redesign of a parent dehydrogenase has not been previously reported and holds promise in the development of carbonyl reductases for application in organic synthesis.Enzymatic NAD or NADP-dependent interconversion of alcohol and carbonyl groups is a key chemical transformation in biology. The thermodynamic equilibrium constant of the reaction usually favors alcohol under a wide range of external conditions. However, the directional preference of biological catalysis, expressed as the ratio of reaction rate constants in direction of carbonyl reduction (k R ) and alcohol oxidation (k O ), is not uniform among natural enzymes and underpins a widely used classification that considers "alcohol dehydrogenases" (k R /k O Յ 1) and "carbonyl reductases" (k R /k O ӷ 1). Horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase and human aldose reductase are representative members of each class, having k R /k O values of ϳ1 (1) and 217 (2), respectively. Work on lactate dehydrogenase has shown that k R /k O is sensitive to active-site structural changes resulting from site-directed mutagenesis (3). However, a clear mechanistic basis for the distinction between dehydrogenases and reductases is currently lacking.The oxyanion binding pocket of PfM2DH (Pseudomonas fluorescens ma...