Just a better taxi? A survey-based comparison of taxis, transit, and ridesourcing services in San Francisco

Abstract

In this study, we present exploratory evidence of how "ridesourcing" services (app-based, ondemand ride services like Uber and Lyft) are used in San Francisco. We explore who uses ridesourcing and for what reasons, how the ridesourcing market compares to that of traditional taxis, and how ridesourcing impacts the use of public transit and overall vehicle travel. In spring 2014, 380 completed intercept surveys were collected from three ridesourcing "hot spots" in San Francisco. We compare survey results with matched-pair taxi trip data and results of a previous taxi user survey. We also compare travel times for ridesourcing and taxis with those for public transit. The findings indicate that, despite many similarities, taxis and ridesourcing differ in user characteristics, wait times, and trips served. While ridesourcing replaces taxi trips, at least half of ridesourcing trips replaced modes other than taxi, including public transit and driving. Impacts on overall vehicle travel are unclear. We conclude with suggestions for future research.

How Can Autonomous and Connected Vehicles, Electromobility, BRT, Hyperloop, Shared Use Mobility and Mobility-As-A-Service Shape Transport Futures for the Context of Smart Cities?

“…More specifically, ride-sourcing dynamically matches travel supply and demand by enabling travellers to request car rides in real-time from potential suppliers using a smartphone application [74]. Ride-splitting is an interesting form of ride-sourcing where riders with similar origins and destinations are matched to the same ride-sourcing driver and vehicle in real-time, and the ride and costs are split among users [63,75].…”

Uber vs. Taxis: Event detection and differentiation in New York City

“…Specifically, TNC user surveys suggest that, relative to taxi users, TNC passengers are younger and posses a higher average level of education (Rayle et al, 2016). Our work continues on this thread by exploring di↵erences in the types of events that are attended by these two groups of passengers.…”

The Rise of Ride Sharing in Urban Transport: Threat or Opportunity?

“…1 It has an estimated market value of over $68 billion. 2 In the case of many cities, ride sharing started to be substitute for the traditional taxicab services in the intra-city public transportation. One recent report found that ride sharing met an average 46% of all total paid car rides through Uber in the major US cities in the irst quarter of 2015, 3 because ride sharing is cheaper than a cab trip.…”

“…This refers to economic eiciency considerations under competitive market conditions. Most importantly, this system eliminates the transaction costs of a taxicab market under regulated market conditions [1,2]. Conversely, the failure of traditional taxicab services stems from distortions inherent in a regulatory process.…”