“It Is Difficult to Always Be an Antagonist”: Ethical, Professional, and Moral Dilemmas as Potentially Psychologically Traumatic Events among Nurses in Canada

Abstract

Aims: We explore social and relational dynamics tied to an unexplored potentially psychologically traumatic event (PPTE) that can impact nurses’ well-being and sense of their occupational responsibilities: namely, the moral, ethical, or professional dilemmas encountered in their occupational work. Design: We used a semi-constructed grounded theory approach to reveal prevalent emergent themes from the qualitative, open-ended component of our survey response data as part of a larger mixed-methods study. Methods: We administered a national Canadian survey on nurses’ experiences of occupational stressors and their health and well-being between May and September 2019. In the current study, we analyzed data from four open text fields in the PPTE section of the survey. Results: In total, at least 109 participants noted that their most impactful PPTE exposure was a moral, professional, and/or ethical dilemma. These participants volunteered the theme as a spontaneous addition to the list of possible PPTE exposures. Conclusions: Emergent theme analytic results suggest that physicians, other nurses, staff, and/or the decision-making power of patients’ families can reduce or eliminate a nurse’s perception of their agency, which directly and negatively impacts their well-being and may cause them to experience moral injury. Nurses also report struggling when left to operationalize patient care instructions with which they disagree. Impact: Nurses are exposed to PPTEs at work, but little is known about factors that can aggravate PPTE exposure in the field, impact the mental wellness of nurses, and even shape patient care. We discuss the implications of PPTE involving moral, professional, and ethical dilemmas (i.e., potentially morally injurious events), and provide recommendations for nursing policy and practice.

Ethical-legal dilemmas of nursing practice in emergencies and disasters: a scoping review

“…These situations tend to lead nursing professionals to face ethical-legal dilemmas, which refer to the psychological impact of having to act differently from what feels morally, ethically or professionally appropriate ( 35 ) . In other words, nursing professionals may be in doubt about the legality of a certain action or procedure that they feel safe to perform, and may end up not carrying it out, even though it could make the difference between life and the death of people, considering that the premise of care in emergencies/disasters is to save/maintain as many lives as possible ( 35 ) .…”

Dilemas ético-legais da prática de enfermagem em emergências e desastres: revisão de escopo

“…Essas situações tendem a levar os profissionais de enfermagem ao enfrentamento de dilemas ético-legais, os quais se referem ao impacto psicológico de ter que agir diferente do que se sente moral, eticamente ou profissionalmente apropriado (35) . Em outras palavras, o profissional de enfermagem pode ficar em dúvida sobre a legalidade de uma determinada ação ou procedimento para o qual se sente seguro para realizar, e pode acabar por não realizá-lo, ainda que possa vir a fazer a diferença entre a vida e a morte de pessoas, considerando que a premissa do atendimento em emergências/desastres é o de salvar/manter o maior número possível de vidas (35) .…”

Ethical dilemmas and illicit acts in nursing: reflections on the legal (dis)order

“…When articulating these two terms, “ethical dilemmas,” we understand that they refer to the psychological impact of having to act other than what feels morally, ethically, or professionally appropriate ( 4 ) . Ethical dilemmas are related to everyday issues present in the work of nursing professionals, who face sensitive situations in their practice in the context of interpersonal relationships between professionals and patients-families-communities.…”