2007
|
Sign up to set email alerts
Is Pulse Synchronized Pneumotonometry More Reproducible than Routine Pneumotonometry and More in Agreement with Goldmann Applanation Tonometry?
Abstract: Pulse synchronized PNT gives more reproducible measurements than routine PNT. The agreement between PNT and GAT is poor.
Search citation statements
Order By: Relevance
Paper Sections
Select...
4
3
0
0
Citation Types
1
7
0
0
Year Published
Range
2009
20092026
2026Publication Types
Select...
7
Relationship
0
7
Authors
Journals
Cited by 7 publications
(8 citation statements)
References 13 publications
1
7
0
0
Order By: Relevance
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…When comparing PN with GAT IOPS, others have reported PN IOPs to be higher than GAT IOPs with a range of mean differences of 1.7–3.4 mmHg. 37 , 39 , 40 This is consistent with our mean difference of 2.03 mmHg. Studies evaluating agreement in IOP between tonometers are likely to be centered around the true effect size, even if they may not all produce identical results.…”
Section: Discussion
supporting
confidence: 91%
“…Consistent with our findings, previous studies have found poor agreement between PN and RT 37 and PN and GAT. 37 , 39 , 40 To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to compare PN and CC. If smaller equivalence bounds were chosen, some of tonometers may not have been considered equivalent with one another under TOST.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 97%
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…When comparing PN with GAT IOPS, others have reported PN IOPs to be higher than GAT IOPs with a range of mean differences of 1.7–3.4 mmHg. 37 , 39 , 40 This is consistent with our mean difference of 2.03 mmHg. Studies evaluating agreement in IOP between tonometers are likely to be centered around the true effect size, even if they may not all produce identical results.…”
Section: Discussion
supporting
confidence: 91%
“…Consistent with our findings, previous studies have found poor agreement between PN and RT 37 and PN and GAT. 37 , 39 , 40 To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to compare PN and CC. If smaller equivalence bounds were chosen, some of tonometers may not have been considered equivalent with one another under TOST.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 97%
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…Regine and colleagues 19 reported that in adults with and without glaucoma, pneumotonometry measured between 1.17–1.37 mm Hg higher than GAT. Similarly, Lafaut and colleagues 20 found that IOP measurements in such adults were approximately 2 mm Hg higher with pneumotonometry than GAT. Our results suggest that the previously observed pattern in adults of pneumotonometry overestimating IOP compared with GAT may apply to children.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 83%
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…28 Munkwitz et al observed that there was a moderate agreement between RT and GAT in normal to moderate elevated IOP, and a poor agreement in the higher IOP range. 29 Although NCT is also widely used the correlation observed between measurements obtained using this type of tonometry and conventional applanation tonometry has never been particularly good (Vernon 1995 21,[30][31][32][33] Several studies have evaluated the RBT and most of these have detected slight overestimation with respect to GAT and a similar influence of corneal thickness on its [34][35][36][37] Studies conducted by (Grieshaber MC et al, Kamppeter BA et al, Kaufmann C et al) have reported a significant positive correlation between GAT and CCT which is similar to our findings. [38][39][40] On the other hand, studies conducted by Schneider E et al, Kniestedt C et al, Ku JY et al found no correlation between GAT values and central corneal thickness which is contrary to what we found.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…When comparing PN with GAT IOPS, others have reported PN IOPs to be higher than GAT IOPs with a range of mean differences of 1.7–3.4 mmHg. 37 , 39 , 40 This is consistent with our mean difference of 2.03 mmHg. Studies evaluating agreement in IOP between tonometers are likely to be centered around the true effect size, even if they may not all produce identical results.…”
Section: Discussion
supporting
confidence: 91%
“…Consistent with our findings, previous studies have found poor agreement between PN and RT 37 and PN and GAT. 37 , 39 , 40 To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to compare PN and CC. If smaller equivalence bounds were chosen, some of tonometers may not have been considered equivalent with one another under TOST.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 97%
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…Regine and colleagues 19 reported that in adults with and without glaucoma, pneumotonometry measured between 1.17–1.37 mm Hg higher than GAT. Similarly, Lafaut and colleagues 20 found that IOP measurements in such adults were approximately 2 mm Hg higher with pneumotonometry than GAT. Our results suggest that the previously observed pattern in adults of pneumotonometry overestimating IOP compared with GAT may apply to children.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 83%
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…28 Munkwitz et al observed that there was a moderate agreement between RT and GAT in normal to moderate elevated IOP, and a poor agreement in the higher IOP range. 29 Although NCT is also widely used the correlation observed between measurements obtained using this type of tonometry and conventional applanation tonometry has never been particularly good (Vernon 1995 21,[30][31][32][33] Several studies have evaluated the RBT and most of these have detected slight overestimation with respect to GAT and a similar influence of corneal thickness on its [34][35][36][37] Studies conducted by (Grieshaber MC et al, Kamppeter BA et al, Kaufmann C et al) have reported a significant positive correlation between GAT and CCT which is similar to our findings. [38][39][40] On the other hand, studies conducted by Schneider E et al, Kniestedt C et al, Ku JY et al found no correlation between GAT values and central corneal thickness which is contrary to what we found.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…When comparing PN with GAT IOPS, others have reported PN IOPs to be higher than GAT IOPs with a range of mean differences of 1.7–3.4 mmHg. 37 , 39 , 40 This is consistent with our mean difference of 2.03 mmHg. Studies evaluating agreement in IOP between tonometers are likely to be centered around the true effect size, even if they may not all produce identical results.…”
Section: Discussion
supporting
confidence: 91%
“…Consistent with our findings, previous studies have found poor agreement between PN and RT 37 and PN and GAT. 37 , 39 , 40 To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to compare PN and CC. If smaller equivalence bounds were chosen, some of tonometers may not have been considered equivalent with one another under TOST.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 97%
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…Regine and colleagues 19 reported that in adults with and without glaucoma, pneumotonometry measured between 1.17–1.37 mm Hg higher than GAT. Similarly, Lafaut and colleagues 20 found that IOP measurements in such adults were approximately 2 mm Hg higher with pneumotonometry than GAT. Our results suggest that the previously observed pattern in adults of pneumotonometry overestimating IOP compared with GAT may apply to children.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 83%
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…28 Munkwitz et al observed that there was a moderate agreement between RT and GAT in normal to moderate elevated IOP, and a poor agreement in the higher IOP range. 29 Although NCT is also widely used the correlation observed between measurements obtained using this type of tonometry and conventional applanation tonometry has never been particularly good (Vernon 1995 21,[30][31][32][33] Several studies have evaluated the RBT and most of these have detected slight overestimation with respect to GAT and a similar influence of corneal thickness on its [34][35][36][37] Studies conducted by (Grieshaber MC et al, Kamppeter BA et al, Kaufmann C et al) have reported a significant positive correlation between GAT and CCT which is similar to our findings. [38][39][40] On the other hand, studies conducted by Schneider E et al, Kniestedt C et al, Ku JY et al found no correlation between GAT values and central corneal thickness which is contrary to what we found.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract