Is oil price risk systemic to sectoral equity markets of an oil importing country? Evidence from a dependence-switching copula delta CoVaR approach

Abstract

In this paper, a dependence-switching copula model is used for the first time to analyse the dependence structure between sectoral equity markets and crude oil prices for India, one of the largest oil importing countries. Specifically, we investigate the dependence and tail dependence for four distinctive states of the market, i.e. rising oil prices-rising equity markets, declining oil prices-declining equity markets, rising oil prices-declining equity markets, and declining oil prices-rising equity markets. Our results reveal that the tail dependence is symmetric (asymmetric) in positive (negative) correlation regimes. Based on the copula results, we estimate the systemic crude oil price risk to different sectors using CoVaR and delta CoVaR. A fleeting positive sectoral CoVaR and delta CoVaR across all sectors implies a time-varying oil price systemic risk. Yet, little difference between CoVaR and VaR across the sectors reveals that a bearish oil market does not add additional systemic risk to a bearish sectoral equity market. The carbon sector is found to be the safe haven investment when both the equity and the oil markets are in a downward phase.

Tail risk connectedness in clean energy and oil financial market

“…In particular, the authors found strong left and right tails relative to the median of the distribution. This result documents the importance of using quantile-based measures over mean-based measures (Saeed et al, 2021 ; Tiwari et al, 2021 ).…”

Risk measurement of China's foreign energy investment portfolio based on Copula-VaR

“…It is also found that the exchange rate markets in China and the United States are not as sensitive to the spillover effects of oil price turmoil. AK Tiwari et al analyzed the dependence relationship between the Indian stock market and crude oil prices using the dependence transformation copula model [28]. Dependence and tail dependence are investigated for four states: oil price-rising-stock-rising, oil price-falling-stock-rising, oil price-falling-stock-rising, and oil price-falling-stock-falling.…”