Intervention fidelity in the definitive cluster randomised controlled trial of the Healthy Lifestyles Programme (HeLP) trial: findings from the process evaluation

Abstract

BackgroundThe Healthy Lifestyles Programme (HeLP) was a novel school-located intervention for 9–10 year olds, designed to prevent obesity by changing patterns of child behaviour through the creation of supportive school and home environments using dynamic and creative delivery methods. This paper reports on both the quantitative and qualitative data regarding the implementation of the HeLP intervention in the definitive cluster randomised controlled trial, which was part of the wider process evaluation.MethodsMixed methods were used to collect data on intervention uptake, fidelity of delivery in terms of content and quality of delivery of the intervention, as well as school and child engagement with the programme. Data were collected using registers of attendance, observations and checklists, field notes, focus groups with children and semi-structured interviews with teachers. Qualitative data were analysed thematically and quantitative data were summarized using descriptive statistics.ResultsAll 16 intervention schools received a complete or near complete programme (94–100%), which was delivered in the spirit in which it had been designed. Of the 676 children in the intervention schools, over 90% of children participated in each phase of HeLP; 92% of children across the socio-economic spectrum were deemed to be engaged with HeLP and qualitative data revealed a high level of enjoyment by all children, particularly to the interactive drama workshops. Further evidence of child engagment with the programme was demonstrated by children’s clear understanding of programme messages around marketing, moderation and food labelling. Thirteen of the intervention schools were deemed to be fully engaged with HeLP and qualitative data revealed a high level of teacher ‘buy in’, due to the programme’s compatability with the National Curriculum, level of teacher support and use of innovative and creative delivery methods by external drama practitioners.ConclusionOur trial shows that it is possible to successfully scale up complex school-based interventions, engage schools and children across the socio-economic spectrum and deliver an intervention as designed. As programme integrity was maintained throughout the HeLP trial, across all intervention schools, we can be confident that the trial findings are a true reflection of the effectiveness of the intervention, enabling policy recommendations to be made.Trial registrationISRCTN15811706.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12966-017-0616-6) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Implementation of triple the time spent on physical education in pre-school to 6th grade: A qualitative study from the programme managers’ perspective

“…Still, it is important to note that core elements of a programme must be delivered in order for it to produce expected impacts (Fixsen, et al, 2005;Howie, Brewer, Brown, Pfeiffer, Saunders, et al, 2014;Lloyd, Dean, Creanor, Abraham, Hillsdon, et al, 2017). In SP, the core delivery consisted of a) 4.5 hours of mandatory PE distributed over at least 3 days a week, b) that all PE teachers participated in professional development courses and c) having a programme promoter.…”

Process Evaluation of Strong Hearts, Healthy Communities: A Rural Community-Based Cardiovascular Disease Prevention Program

“…22,24 Integrating quantitative and qualitative data from multiple sources is often recommended to provide a more comprehensive assessment of program implementation. 25 Qualitative methods, such as focus groups, are especially valuable as they allow participants' experiences to inform program modifications. By documenting successful and challenging aspects of program content and delivery, qualitative findings can help tailor intervention components to meet specific community needs.…”

Process evaluation of a pilot multi-component physical activity intervention – active schools: Skelmersdale

“…UK Medical Research Council (MRC) guidelines suggest that both quantitative and qualitative methods have an important role in process evaluations, both independently and in combination [23]. Traditionally, school-based process evaluation studies have utilised methodologies such as teacher surveys, measures of child enjoyment, and registers of attendance [25–28]. However, methodological limitations are associated with some of these approaches.…”

“…Furthermore, quantitative approaches provide limited information on the physical environment such as the setting within school which PA is taking place and also the social environment such as who children are taking part in PA with. Systematic observations of PA are said to be advantageous as they can provide such contextual understanding [28]. Observations of interventions in practice have therefore also been used in process evaluation studies [24, 28].…”

“…Systematic observations of PA are said to be advantageous as they can provide such contextual understanding [28]. Observations of interventions in practice have therefore also been used in process evaluation studies [24, 28].…”