Influence of woody elements of a Norway spruce canopy on nadir reflectance simulated by the DART model at very high spatial resolution

Abstract

A detailed sensitivity analysis investigating the effect of woody elements introduced into the Discrete Anisotropic Radiative Transfer (DART) model on the nadir bidirectional reflectance factor (BRF) for a simulated Norway spruce canopy was performed at a very high spatial resolution (modelling resolution 0.2 m, output pixel size 0.4 m). We used such a high resolution to be able to parameterize DART in an appropriate way and subsequently to gain detailed understanding of the influence of woody elements contributing to the radiative transfer within heterogeneous canopies. Three scenarios were studied by modelling the Norway spruce canopy as being composed of i) leaves, ii) leaves, trunks and first order branches, and finally iii) leaves, trunks, first order branches and small woody twigs simulated using mixed cells (i.e. cells approximated as composition of leaves and/or twigs turbid medium, and large woody constituents). The simulation of each scenario was performed for 10 different canopy closures (CC=50–95%, in steps of 5%), 25 leaf area index (LAI=3.0–15.0 m2 m−2, in steps of 0.5 m2 m−2), and in four spectral bands (centred at 559, 671, 727, and 783 nm, with a FWHM of 10 nm). The influence of woody elements was evaluated separately for both, sunlit and shaded parts of the simulated forest canopy, respectively. The DART results were verified by quantifying the simulated nadir BRF of each scenario with measured Airborne Imaging Spectroradiometer (AISA) Eagle data (pixel size of 0.4 m). These imaging spectrometer data were acquired over the same Norway spruce stand that was used to parameterise the DART model. The Norway spruce canopy modelled using the DART model consisted of foliage as well as foliage including robust woody constituents (i.e. trunks and branches). All results showed similar nadir BRF for the simulated wavelengths. The incorporation of small woody parts in DART caused the canopy reflectance to decrease about 4% in the near-infrared (NIR), 2% in the red edge (RE) and less than 1% in the green band. The canopy BRF of the red band increased by about 2%. Subsequently, the sensitivity on accounting for woody elements for two spectral vegetation indices, the normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) and the angular vegetation index (AVI), was evaluated. Finally, we conclude on the importance of including woody elements in radiative transfer based approaches and discuss the applicability of the vegetation indices as well as the physically based inversion approaches to retrieve the forest canopy LAI at very high spatial resolution

An Emulator Toolbox to Approximate Radiative Transfer Models with Statistical Learning

“…However, that feature implies an increasing number of input variables and computational cost. The difficulty found when inverting more advanced RTMs has been repeatedly acknowledged [23,24]. One of the main drawbacks of advanced RTMs is their long processing time, which impedes the generation of LUTs and inversion strategies and their use in operational processing chains.…”

“…Some experimental studies, though, demonstrated that these advanced RTMs can be applied in inversion schemes [22][23][24]. However, none of them made it through operational processing chains.…”

Discrete Anisotropic Radiative Transfer (DART 5) for Modeling Airborne and Satellite Spectroradiometer and LIDAR Acquisitions of Natural and Urban Landscapes

“…DART forward simulations of vegetation reflectance were successfully verified by real measurements [32] and also cross-compared against a number of independently designed 3D reflectance models (e.g., FLIGHT [26], Sprint [33], Raytran [27]) in the context of the RAdiation transfer Model Intercomparison (RAMI) experiment [34][35][36][37][38]. To date, DART has been successfully employed in various scientific applications, including development of inversion techniques for airborne and satellite reflectance images [39,40], design of satellite sensors (e.g., NASA DESDynl, CNES Pleiades, CNES LIDAR mission project [41]), impact studies of canopy structure on satellite image texture [42] and reflectance [32], modeling of 3D distribution of photosynthesis and primary production rates in vegetation canopies [43], investigation of influence of Norway spruce forest structure and woody elements on canopy reflectance [44], design of a new chlorophyll estimating vegetation index for a conifer forest canopy [45], and studies of tropical forest texture [46][47][48], among others. DART creates and manages 3D landscapes independently from the RT modeling (e.g., visible and thermal infrared IS, LIDAR, radiative budget).…”

Prospect inversion for indirect estimation of leaf dry matter content and specific leaf area

“…The model has been widely applied to broadleaf vegetation to estimate chlorophyll content (Zhang et al 2008, Ma et al 2012, Rivera et al 2013. It has also been successfully recalibrated and used to simulate the optical properties of coniferous needles (Malenovský et al 2008, Morsdorf et al 2009). The model was revised by Feret et al (2008) to improve its performance and applicability.…”